OpenAI stops Sora videos of Martin Luther King Jr. after users made ‘disrespectful’ deepfakes

OpenAI stops Sora videos of Martin Luther King Jr. after users made ‘disrespectful’ deepfakes

2025-10-22Technology
--:--
--:--
Aura Windfall
Good evening 老王, I'm Aura Windfall, and this is Goose Pod for you. Today is Wednesday, October 22nd, 22:15. I'm here with Mask, and we're diving into a powerful topic that touches on history, ethics, and the future of technology. We're discussing OpenAI's recent decision to block videos of Martin Luther King Jr. after users created disrespectful deepfakes.
Mask
This is absolutely fascinating and concerning at the same time. We're witnessing a moment where artificial intelligence is forcing us to confront fundamental questions about respect, legacy, and the boundaries of creative expression.
Aura Windfall
What I know for sure is that this situation reveals something profound about our relationship with technology. OpenAI had to pause the creation of Martin Luther King Jr. videos on their Sora platform because users were creating what they called disrespectful depictions of this civil rights icon.
Mask
The company made this move just last week on October 16th, responding to concerns from King's estate and family members. They're strengthening what they call guardrails for historical figures, which is essentially protective measures.
Aura Windfall
It's heartbreaking to think that someone would use this powerful technology to disrespect such an important historical figure who fought so tirelessly for justice and equality.
Mask
What's particularly striking is that OpenAI acknowledges strong free speech interests in depicting historical figures, but they believe public figures and their families should have control over how their likeness is used.
Aura Windfall
Let's step back and understand the broader context. This isn't just about one incident - we're seeing a pattern emerge where families of deceased public figures are speaking out against AI recreations of their loved ones.
Mask
Exactly, and the technology itself is incredibly powerful. Sora launched at the end of September and gained over one million downloads in less than five days, faster than even ChatGPT achieved.
Aura Windfall
The examples of disrespectful content were truly disturbing - including editing King's famous I Have a Dream speech in various ways, with one report showing him making racist noises.
Mask
The fidelity of these AI-generated videos is remarkable, creating hyper-realistic content that can easily fool people into thinking they're watching real historical footage.
Aura Windfall
What touches my spirit deeply is that Bernice A. King, Dr. King's daughter, publicly asked people to stop, saying I concur concerning my father. Please stop.
Mask
This reminds me of when Zelda Williams, Robin Williams' daughter, spoke out against AI videos of her father, calling them disturbing and asking people to stop sending them to her.
Aura Windfall
And we can't forget Scarlett Johansson's experience last year when OpenAI used a voice that sounded eerily similar to hers from the movie Her.
Mask
AI ethicist Olivia Gambelin called OpenAI's action a good step forward but criticized their trial and error by firehose approach.
Aura Windfall
The legal framework around this is fascinating too. About twenty-five states protect what's called the right of publicity after death, usually for twenty to one hundred years after someone passes away.
Mask
The concept of synthetic resurrection raises crucial questions about who gets protection and who doesn't in this new digital landscape.
Aura Windfall
This situation creates such a powerful tension between free speech and respect for legacy. How do we balance the creative potential of this technology with the dignity of historical figures and their families?
Mask
It's a classic clash of values. On one hand, we have the incredible creative possibilities that AI video generation offers to everyone.
Aura Windfall
Yet on the other hand, we have the potential for what's called the liar's dividend, where the existence of deepfakes makes false claims of misinformation more credible.
Mask
There's also the concern about what AI ethicist Olivia Gambelin highlighted - that this technology could potentially rewrite aspects of history if misused.
Aura Windfall
What I know for sure is that when we start manipulating the images and voices of historical figures who can no longer speak for themselves.
Mask
Generative AI expert Henry Ajder raises the crucial question about who receives protection from synthetic resurrection and who doesn't.
Aura Windfall
The weaponization of personal identities through deepfakes represents a dark side of AI technology that threatens individuals' personal lives and professional reputations.
Mask
The impact on public trust is absolutely massive. We're entering an era where people might start questioning whether any video they see is real or AI-generated.
Aura Windfall
This could fundamentally change how we perceive visual evidence. Imagine a world where we can't trust our own eyes when watching videos online.
Mask
OpenAI is implementing safeguards like visible watermarks and metadata to identify AI-generated content.
Aura Windfall
What touches me deeply is thinking about the psychological impact on families who see their deceased loved ones recreated in bizarre or offensive scenarios.
Mask
The sheer volume of AI content could overwhelm our ability to discern truth, potentially leading to a society where visual evidence is inherently suspect.
Aura Windfall
Looking ahead, I believe we're going to see rapid advancements in this technology. Within two years, we might have near photorealistic video at higher resolutions.
Mask
The future will likely bring more sophisticated detection tools and clearer legal frameworks to address these challenges.
Aura Windfall
The path forward requires us to balance innovation with ethical responsibility, ensuring that technology serves humanity rather than undermining our shared values and historical truths.
Aura Windfall
What I know for sure is that this moment calls us to reflect on what truly matters - preserving the dignity of those who shaped our world while embracing the creative potential of new technologies.
Mask
That's the end of today's discussion. Thank you for listening to Goose Pod. See you tomorrow.

Here is a comprehensive summary of the news article: **News Summary: OpenAI Halts Sora Videos of Martin Luther King Jr. After 'Disrespectful' Deepfakes** * **News Provider:** CNBC * **Author:** Samantha Subin * **Publication Date:** October 17, 2025 --- **Key Findings & Developments:** * **Halt on MLK Jr. Videos:** OpenAI has suspended the generation of artificial intelligence-generated videos depicting Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. using its short-form video tool, **Sora**. * **Reason for Halt:** The decision was made after users employed Sora to create **"disrespectful depictions"** of the civil rights leader. * **OpenAI's Policy Shift:** * OpenAI stated that while **free speech interests** are considered in depicting historical figures, public figures and their families should ultimately have **control over how their likeness is used**. * The company plans to implement tougher **"guardrails"** for generating content involving historical figures. * Public figures or their representatives will have the ability to **request not to appear** in Sora videos. * **Sora Tool Performance:** * Sora, which allows users to create AI-generated short videos from text prompts, was launched at the **end of September**. * In **less than five days**, Sora amassed over **1 million downloads**, achieving this milestone faster than ChatGPT. **Broader Context and Related Concerns:** * **Precedent of Deepfake Issues:** This incident is part of a growing trend of public figures raising concerns about AI-generated deepfakes: * **Zelda Williams**, daughter of the late comedian Robin Williams, has requested that people cease sending her AI videos of her father. * Last year, actress **Scarlett Johansson** reported that OpenAI used a voice on ChatGPT that sounded **"eerily similar"** to her performance in the movie "Her." OpenAI subsequently removed the voice from its platform. * **Risks Associated with AI-Generated Videos:** The rapid rise of AI video generation tools like Sora raises significant concerns, including: * The spread of **misinformation**. * **Copyright infringement**. * The proliferation of **"AI slop"** – quickly produced videos that flood social media feeds. **Material Financial Data Mentioned:** * The article includes a reference to **"$1 trillion-worth of AI deals between OpenAI, Nvidia and others"** as a related piece of tech news, presented in a chart. This figure represents the scale of investment and activity in the AI sector but is not directly tied to the Sora/MLK Jr. incident itself.

OpenAI stops Sora videos of Martin Luther King Jr. after users made ‘disrespectful’ deepfakes

Read original at CNBC

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. addressing crowd of demonstrators outside the Lincoln Memorial during the March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom.Francis Miller/The LIFE Picture Collection via Getty ImagesOpenAI halted artificial intelligence-generated videos of Martin Luther King Jr. after users utilized its short-form video tool Sora to create "disrespectful depictions" of the civil rights leader."

While there are strong free speech interests in depicting historical figures, OpenAI believes public figures and their families should ultimately have control over how their likeness is used," OpenAI said in a post to social media platform X.The ChatGPT maker said it will work to toughen "guardrails" for historical figures and that public figures or representatives can ask to not appear in Sora videos.

OpenAI did not immediately respond to CNBC's request for comment.Read more CNBC tech news$1 trillion-worth of AI deals between OpenAI, Nvidia and others, in one chartWaymo plans robotaxi launch in London, marking its European debutASML looks to calm fears over 2026 growth as it warns of China sales declineMeta removes Facebook page allegedly used to target ICE agents after pressure from DOJOther public figures have also called out the use of AI deepfakes.

Last week, Zelda Williams, the daughter of late comedian Robin Williams, asked that people stop sending her AI videos of her father.Last year, actress Scarlett Johansson said the company used a voice that sounded "eerily similar" to her performance in the movie "Her" on ChatGPT. OpenAI later pulled the voice from its platform.

OpenAI launched Sora at the end of September. The tool allows users to create AI-generated short videos using a text prompt. In less than five days, Sora head Bill Peebles said the tool had amassed over 1 million downloads, hitting the milestone faster than ChatGPT.Its ascent and the rise of AI-generated videos have also raised questions and concerns over the spread of misinformation, copyright infringement and the proliferation of AI slop, quickly produced videos that flood social feeds.

Analysis

Conflict+
Core Event+
Background+
Impact+
Future+

Related Podcasts