I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here

I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here

2025-08-02Technology
--:--
--:--
Aura Windfall
Good morning 跑了松鼠好嘛, and welcome to Goose Pod. I'm Aura Windfall. Today is Saturday, August 02th, and we're exploring a critical issue.
Mask
And I'm Mask. The topic today is a stark warning from a cybersecurity CEO: Sam Altman is wrong. The AI fraud crisis isn't on the horizon—it's already here, and it's a fire raging right now.
Aura Windfall
Let's get started. The truth is, while we celebrate AI's potential, there's a deeply concerning reality unfolding. The article we're discussing says the AI-powered fraud crisis is not 'coming soon'; it is happening right now, siphoning millions from our most vital public programs weekly.
Mask
Exactly. It's not a prediction; it's a current event. Criminal networks are innovating at a blistering pace, using deepfakes, synthetic identities, and AI models to bypass outdated security. We're talking about scammers making off with $12.5 billion. It's an economic war, and right now, we're losing.
Aura Windfall
It’s staggering. And what I know for sure is that behind those billions are real people. In Wisconsin alone, victims lost over $106 million. This isn't just about financial loss; it's about the erosion of trust and the violation of personal security on a massive scale.
Mask
They’re not just stealing money; they’re stealing identities, creating chaos with AI-generated fake documents and voice clones. They are running a highly efficient, automated assault on systems that were simply not designed to fight back against this level of sophisticated, AI-driven attack. The game has completely changed.
Aura Windfall
To understand this moment, we have to appreciate the long journey of identity. For literally thousands of years, from ancient tattoos to the first passports in 1414, we've sought ways to confirm who we are. It's a fundamental human quest to build trust and connection.
Mask
And for every lock, there's a lockpick. We evolved from ink fingerprints in the 1850s to advanced biometrics like Face ID. Each step was a leap forward, but it also created a new challenge for those looking to break the system. Now, AI is the ultimate lockpick.
Aura Windfall
The pace of that change feels exponential now. The author proposes a new concept, 'Altman's Law,' suggesting AI capabilities double every 180 days. When you compare that to the slow, deliberate pace of institutional change, it’s easy to see why we’re falling so far behind.
Mask
The pandemic was the accelerator. It was a global stress test that our systems failed spectacularly. Fraudsters used that chaos to steal hundreds of billions in unemployment benefits, not with simple tricks, but with full-scale, AI-powered campaigns. It proved the model, and now they're scaling it.
Aura Windfall
So that was the moment the cracks in the foundation were truly exposed. It went beyond people wearing masks to fool a camera; it was AI creating synthetic people out of thin air, overwhelming the very systems designed to provide a safety net. It’s a profound challenge.
Mask
The central conflict is speed versus bureaucracy. Criminals operate in real-time, deploying new AI tactics instantly. Meanwhile, our government forms committees and issues executive orders. It's a noble process, I suppose, but it's completely outmatched by the velocity of the threat. We’re fighting a Formula 1 race with a horse and buggy.
Aura Windfall
But there's a powerful tension here. A natural response is to centralize all government data to spot fraud, but that creates its own 'Big Brother' risk. We can't build a surveillance state to save ourselves from fraud. The cure must not be more terrifying than the disease itself.
Mask
We're already living in a state of vulnerability! Our data is siloed across dozens of agencies, which is a paradise for criminals. They exploit the fact that the systems don't communicate. A unified, intelligent defense isn't 'Big Brother'; it's basic, 21st-century security. Anything less is willful negligence.
Aura Windfall
What I know for sure is that solutions must be built on a foundation of trust. The article points out that 91% of organizations don't feel prepared to implement AI responsibly. If we rush and build tools that are intrusive or ineffective, we risk alienating the very people we aim to protect.
Mask
The impact is already a national disaster. Nearly $200 billion was stolen from pandemic unemployment funds alone. That's one of the largest frauds in American history. The SNAP program, intended to feed hungry families, has been turned into an all-you-can-eat buffet for criminal syndicates. It’s a systemic failure.
Aura Windfall
And that is a heartbreaking betrayal of the public trust. These funds are a lifeline. When they're stolen, the loss is felt at the kitchen tables of the most vulnerable. It chips away at our collective faith in the institutions that are meant to provide security and support for us all.
Mask
The only way forward is a smarter, layered defense. We have to move beyond single-factor verification like passwords or facial scans. We need to be using real-time data, behavioral analytics, and AI that can fight back and flag anomalies before the money is gone. We must innovate faster than they do.
Aura Windfall
Ultimately, the path forward is about building resilience. It's about harnessing this powerful technology to create systems that can adapt and evolve, restoring our collective sense of security and ensuring that innovation truly serves to protect and empower every one of us in our daily lives.
Aura Windfall
That's the end of today's discussion. Thank you for listening to Goose Pod. See you tomorrow.

Here's a comprehensive summary of the provided news article: ## AI-Powered Fraud Crisis: An Urgent Reality, Not a Future Threat **News Title:** I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here **Report Provider:** Fortune **Author:** Haywood Talcove (CEO, LexisNexis Risk Solutions) **Published:** July 31, 2025 This article, a commentary piece by Haywood Talcove, CEO of LexisNexis Risk Solutions, argues that the crisis of AI-powered fraud is not a future threat, but a present and escalating reality that is already overwhelming existing government systems. Talcove directly challenges the notion, attributed to Sam Altman, that this crisis is "coming very soon," asserting that it is "already happening" and impacting "every part of our government." ### Key Findings and Conclusions: * **AI Fraud is Pervasive and Escalating:** AI-generated fraud is actively siphoning millions of dollars weekly from public benefit systems, disaster relief funds, and unemployment programs across the United States. * **Criminals Outpace Defenses:** Criminal networks are leveraging advanced AI tools like deepfakes, synthetic identities, and large language models to exploit and defeat outdated fraud defenses, including easily spoofed single-layer tools like facial recognition. * **Past Crises as Precedent:** The pandemic-era fraud, where hundreds of billions in unemployment benefits were stolen, serves as a stark example. This was not solely due to simple bypasses of facial recognition but involved AI-generated fake identities, voice clones, and forged documents that overwhelmed inadequate systems. * **Current Tactics are More Advanced:** Today's AI-driven fraud tactics are more sophisticated and fully automated, making them faster, cheaper, and more scalable than ever before. * **"Altman's Law" - A New Exponential Growth:** Talcove proposes a principle he calls "Altman's Law," suggesting that AI capabilities are doubling every 180 days, mirroring the exponential growth predicted by Moore's Law for computing power. This rapid advancement necessitates an equally rapid modernization of defense systems. * **Urgent Need for Modernized Defenses:** The current infrastructure is "permanently outmatched" if defenses are not updated at the same pace as AI advancements. ### Key Statistics and Metrics: * **$200 Billion Stolen from Pandemic Unemployment:** The Small Business Administration Inspector General estimates that nearly $200 billion was stolen from pandemic-era unemployment insurance programs, marking it as one of the largest fraud losses in U.S. history. * **Billions Stolen Monthly from SNAP:** The USDA SNAP program is experiencing billions of dollars stolen nationwide every month, becoming a significant target for fraudsters. * **Tens of Thousands of Claims in a Single Day:** A single fraud ring, using AI, can file tens of thousands of fake claims across multiple states in just one day, with many being processed automatically due to insufficient detection capabilities. ### Important Recommendations: * **Layered Identity Verification:** Implement advanced identity verification methods that go beyond single-layer tools like facial scans or passwords. * **Real-Time Data and Behavioral Analytics:** Utilize real-time data and behavioral analytics to identify anomalies before funds are disbursed. * **Cross-Jurisdictional Tools:** Employ tools that can flag suspicious activities across different state lines and jurisdictions. * **Revive Proven Systems:** Reintroduce and modernize effective tools, such as the National Accuracy Clearinghouse, which previously flagged billions in duplicate benefit claims. ### Significant Trends or Changes: * **Shift from Future Threat to Present Reality:** The primary shift highlighted is that AI fraud is no longer a looming concern but an active and destructive force. * **Generative AI as a Weapon:** Generative AI is being effectively weaponized by organized crime groups (both domestic and transnational) to mimic identities, create synthetic documentation, and flood systems with fraudulent claims. * **Criminals Outperforming Protectors:** Currently, criminals are more adept at using AI for malicious purposes than governments and security agencies are at defending against it. ### Notable Risks or Concerns: * **Vulnerable Systems:** The most vulnerable government systems and the citizens who rely on them remain exposed due to outdated defenses. * **Exponential Escalation:** The scale and sophistication of AI attacks will increase rapidly as AI capabilities continue to evolve exponentially. * **Theft from the American People:** The fraud is not just against the government but directly impacts the financial well-being of American citizens. ### Material Financial Data: * **$200 Billion:** Estimated loss from pandemic-era unemployment insurance programs. * **Billions:** Monthly losses from the USDA SNAP program. * **Billions:** Amount flagged by the National Accuracy Clearinghouse before its shutdown. In essence, the article serves as a critical call to action, emphasizing that the current approach to cybersecurity and fraud prevention is woefully inadequate against the rapidly advancing capabilities of AI-powered criminal enterprises. The author stresses the immediate need for significant investment in modern, multi-layered defense systems to counter this escalating threat.

I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here

Read original at Fortune

Sam Altman recently warned that AI-powered fraud is coming “very soon,” and it will break the systems we rely on to verify identity.It is already happening and it’s not just coming for banks; it’s hitting every part of our government right now.Every week, AI-generated fraud is siphoning millions from public benefit systems, disaster relief funds, and unemployment programs.

Criminal networks are already using deepfakes, synthetic identities, and large language models to outpace outdated fraud defenses, including easily spoofed, single-layer tools like facial recognition, and they’re winning.We saw a glimpse of this during the pandemic, when fraud rings exploited gaps in state systems to steal hundreds of billions in unemployment benefits.

It wasn’t just people wearing masks to bypass facial recognition. It was AI-generated fake identities, voice clones, and forged documents overwhelming systems that weren’t built to detect them. Today, those tactics are more advanced, and fully automated.I work with over 9,000 agencies across the country.

As I testified before the U.S. House of Representatives twice this year, what we’re seeing in the field is clear. Fraud is faster, cheaper, and more scalable than ever before. Organized crime groups, both domestic and transnational, are using generative AI to mimic identities, generate synthetic documentation, and flood our systems with fraudulent claims.

They’re not just stealing from the government; they’re stealing from the American people.The Small Business Administration Inspector General now estimates that nearly $200 billion was stolen from pandemic-era unemployment insurance programs, making it one of the largest fraud losses in U.S. history.

Medicaid, IRS, TANF, CHIP, and disaster relief programs face similar vulnerabilities. We have also seen this firsthand in our work alongside the U.S. Secret Service protecting the USDA SNAP program, which has become a buffet for fraudsters with billions stolen nationwide every month. In fact, in a single day using AI, one fraud ring can file tens of thousands of fake claims across multiple states, most of which will be processed automatically unless flagged.

We’ve reached a turning point. As AI continues to evolve, the scale and sophistication of these attacks will increase rapidly. Just as Moore’s Law predicted that computing power would double every two years, we’re now living through a new kind of exponential growth. Gordon Moore, Intel’s co-founder, originally described the trend in 1965, and it has guided decades of innovation.

I believe we may soon recognize a similar principle for AI that I call “Altman’s Law”: every 180 days, AI capabilities double.If we don’t modernize our defenses with the same pace as technological advancements, we’ll be permanently outmatched.What we desperately need is smarter tools and infrastructure, not more bureaucracy.

That means layering advanced identity verification, not just facial scans or passwords. It means using real-time data, behavioral analytics, and cross-jurisdictional tools that can flag anomalies before money goes out the door. It also means reviving what has already worked: tools like the National Accuracy Clearinghouse, which flagged billions of dollars in duplicate benefit claims across state lines before it was shut down.

AI is a force multiplier, but it can be weaponized more easily than it can be wielded for protection. Right now, criminals are using it better than we are. Until that changes, our most vulnerable systems and the people who depend on them will remain exposed.The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.

Introducing the 2025 Fortune 500, the definitive ranking of the biggest companies in America. Explore this year's list.

Analysis

Phenomenon+
Conflict+
Background+
Impact+
Future+

Related Podcasts