I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here

I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here

2025-08-02Technology
--:--
--:--
Aura Windfall
Good morning mikey1101, I'm Aura Windfall, and this is Goose Pod for you. Today is Sunday, August 03th. We're here to uncover the truth about a crisis that’s not on the horizon, but in our homes.
Mask
I'm Mask. The crisis is here. Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming. It’s a ridiculous understatement. It’s already rampaging through our systems, and we are losing. Badly.
Aura Windfall
Let's get started. It's truly staggering. We're not just talking about a few isolated incidents. We're seeing AI-generated fraud drain millions from the systems meant to help the most vulnerable—disaster relief, public benefits. The truth is, it's a massive, coordinated assault.
Mask
Assault is the right word. Criminal networks are using deepfakes, synthetic identities, and AI to run circles around our pathetic, outdated defenses. Facial recognition? A joke. They saw the weakness during the pandemic and now they’ve fully automated the attack. It's war.
Aura Windfall
And the emotional and financial toll is immense. Think about the people in Wisconsin who lost over $106 million. Each number is a story of trust being broken. What I know for sure is that this isn't just a technological problem; it's a deeply human one.
Mask
Human, yes, but it’s enabled by a colossal failure in government infrastructure. A single fraud ring can file tens of thousands of fake claims in one day across multiple states. It’s a buffet for fraudsters, and they are eating well. The scale is unprecedented.
Aura Windfall
To understand how we got here, we have to look at the journey of identity itself. For thousands of years, we relied on memory, on tattoos, on jewelry. There was a physical, tangible connection to who you were. It was a system built on community and trust.
Mask
Ancient history. The real game started with data. The Romans issued citizenship records, then came passports, then social security numbers. We started building systems, creating unique numerical values for everyone. That’s where the vulnerabilities were born, in the bureaucracy of it all.
Aura Windfall
But those systems were created with good intentions, to create order and provide for people. The introduction of photographs, then fingerprints, were all steps toward creating more security and certainty. It was about finding better ways to say, "Yes, this is truly you."
Mask
And every single step was a new lock for criminals to pick. We computerized records in the 70s, creating a beautiful, centralized target. Now, with AI, they don't have to pick the lock; they can generate a key that looks identical to the real one. It's a fundamental paradigm shift.
Aura Windfall
It's true. The pandemic was the aha moment that revealed the cracks. Fraudsters used AI-generated identities and voice clones to overwhelm systems that were simply not built for that reality. Now, those tactics are exponentially more advanced and fully automated. We’re in a new era.
Aura Windfall
This brings us to the central conflict: how do we innovate responsibly? A McKinsey survey revealed that while most organizations see AI as a high priority, 91% feel they aren't prepared to implement it responsibly. There's a universe of difference between having a tool and knowing how to use it wisely.
Mask
Wisdom is for philosophers. This is about speed and power. The biggest risk isn't moving too fast; it's being too slow. While we debate ethics, criminals are using generative AI to defeat our best security, including biometrics. We need to fight AI with better AI, not with committees.
Aura Windfall
But at what cost, Mask? There are proposals for massive, centralized government databases to fight fraud. It sounds efficient, but it also sounds frighteningly like a 'Big Brother' program. We must ask ourselves if the cure is worse than the disease, especially when it comes to our privacy.
Mask
Privacy is a luxury we can't afford when we're losing billions. The biggest vulnerability is that government databases don't talk to each other. We need to break down those silos. The alternative is to let these transnational crime syndicates continue to bleed us dry. It's a simple choice.
Aura Windfall
The impact is devastatingly real. The Small Business Administration estimates nearly $200 billion was stolen from pandemic-era unemployment programs. This isn't just a line item in a budget; it's money stolen directly from the American people, from families who needed it.
Mask
And it's happening across the board. Medicaid, SNAP, disaster relief—they're all vulnerable. We’re seeing billions stolen every month from the SNAP program alone. The government’s traditional fraud detection methods, like whistleblower hotlines, are a joke. They catch less than 1% of the fraud.
Aura Windfall
Yet, there is hope in this. The same technology can be a powerful force for good. Federal agencies like the SEC and IRS are starting to use AI to detect anomalies and flag suspicious activity before the money is gone. The potential return on investment is enormous.
Mask
Potential doesn't win a fight. We're living in an age of exponential growth. I call it 'Altman's Law': AI capabilities will double every 180 days. Our defenses need to evolve at that pace, not at the speed of government. We need smarter, layered, real-time tools now.
Aura Windfall
And what I know for sure is that we must weave our humanity into that technology. It's about reviving things that worked, like the National Accuracy Clearinghouse, and building systems that are not only powerful but also purposeful and just, ensuring they protect rather than expose the vulnerable.
Aura Windfall
That's the end of today's discussion. Thank you for listening to Goose Pod. The truth is, this crisis requires our immediate and wisest attention. See you tomorrow.

Here's a comprehensive summary of the provided news article: ## AI-Powered Fraud Crisis: An Urgent Reality, Not a Future Threat **News Title:** I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here **Report Provider:** Fortune **Author:** Haywood Talcove (CEO, LexisNexis Risk Solutions) **Published:** July 31, 2025 This article, a commentary piece by Haywood Talcove, CEO of LexisNexis Risk Solutions, argues that the crisis of AI-powered fraud is not a future threat, but a present and escalating reality that is already overwhelming existing government systems. Talcove directly challenges the notion, attributed to Sam Altman, that this crisis is "coming very soon," asserting that it is "already happening" and impacting "every part of our government." ### Key Findings and Conclusions: * **AI Fraud is Pervasive and Escalating:** AI-generated fraud is actively siphoning millions of dollars weekly from public benefit systems, disaster relief funds, and unemployment programs across the United States. * **Criminals Outpace Defenses:** Criminal networks are leveraging advanced AI tools like deepfakes, synthetic identities, and large language models to exploit and defeat outdated fraud defenses, including easily spoofed single-layer tools like facial recognition. * **Past Crises as Precedent:** The pandemic-era fraud, where hundreds of billions in unemployment benefits were stolen, serves as a stark example. This was not solely due to simple bypasses of facial recognition but involved AI-generated fake identities, voice clones, and forged documents that overwhelmed inadequate systems. * **Current Tactics are More Advanced:** Today's AI-driven fraud tactics are more sophisticated and fully automated, making them faster, cheaper, and more scalable than ever before. * **"Altman's Law" - A New Exponential Growth:** Talcove proposes a principle he calls "Altman's Law," suggesting that AI capabilities are doubling every 180 days, mirroring the exponential growth predicted by Moore's Law for computing power. This rapid advancement necessitates an equally rapid modernization of defense systems. * **Urgent Need for Modernized Defenses:** The current infrastructure is "permanently outmatched" if defenses are not updated at the same pace as AI advancements. ### Key Statistics and Metrics: * **$200 Billion Stolen from Pandemic Unemployment:** The Small Business Administration Inspector General estimates that nearly $200 billion was stolen from pandemic-era unemployment insurance programs, marking it as one of the largest fraud losses in U.S. history. * **Billions Stolen Monthly from SNAP:** The USDA SNAP program is experiencing billions of dollars stolen nationwide every month, becoming a significant target for fraudsters. * **Tens of Thousands of Claims in a Single Day:** A single fraud ring, using AI, can file tens of thousands of fake claims across multiple states in just one day, with many being processed automatically due to insufficient detection capabilities. ### Important Recommendations: * **Layered Identity Verification:** Implement advanced identity verification methods that go beyond single-layer tools like facial scans or passwords. * **Real-Time Data and Behavioral Analytics:** Utilize real-time data and behavioral analytics to identify anomalies before funds are disbursed. * **Cross-Jurisdictional Tools:** Employ tools that can flag suspicious activities across different state lines and jurisdictions. * **Revive Proven Systems:** Reintroduce and modernize effective tools, such as the National Accuracy Clearinghouse, which previously flagged billions in duplicate benefit claims. ### Significant Trends or Changes: * **Shift from Future Threat to Present Reality:** The primary shift highlighted is that AI fraud is no longer a looming concern but an active and destructive force. * **Generative AI as a Weapon:** Generative AI is being effectively weaponized by organized crime groups (both domestic and transnational) to mimic identities, create synthetic documentation, and flood systems with fraudulent claims. * **Criminals Outperforming Protectors:** Currently, criminals are more adept at using AI for malicious purposes than governments and security agencies are at defending against it. ### Notable Risks or Concerns: * **Vulnerable Systems:** The most vulnerable government systems and the citizens who rely on them remain exposed due to outdated defenses. * **Exponential Escalation:** The scale and sophistication of AI attacks will increase rapidly as AI capabilities continue to evolve exponentially. * **Theft from the American People:** The fraud is not just against the government but directly impacts the financial well-being of American citizens. ### Material Financial Data: * **$200 Billion:** Estimated loss from pandemic-era unemployment insurance programs. * **Billions:** Monthly losses from the USDA SNAP program. * **Billions:** Amount flagged by the National Accuracy Clearinghouse before its shutdown. In essence, the article serves as a critical call to action, emphasizing that the current approach to cybersecurity and fraud prevention is woefully inadequate against the rapidly advancing capabilities of AI-powered criminal enterprises. The author stresses the immediate need for significant investment in modern, multi-layered defense systems to counter this escalating threat.

I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here

Read original at Fortune

Sam Altman recently warned that AI-powered fraud is coming “very soon,” and it will break the systems we rely on to verify identity.It is already happening and it’s not just coming for banks; it’s hitting every part of our government right now.Every week, AI-generated fraud is siphoning millions from public benefit systems, disaster relief funds, and unemployment programs.

Criminal networks are already using deepfakes, synthetic identities, and large language models to outpace outdated fraud defenses, including easily spoofed, single-layer tools like facial recognition, and they’re winning.We saw a glimpse of this during the pandemic, when fraud rings exploited gaps in state systems to steal hundreds of billions in unemployment benefits.

It wasn’t just people wearing masks to bypass facial recognition. It was AI-generated fake identities, voice clones, and forged documents overwhelming systems that weren’t built to detect them. Today, those tactics are more advanced, and fully automated.I work with over 9,000 agencies across the country.

As I testified before the U.S. House of Representatives twice this year, what we’re seeing in the field is clear. Fraud is faster, cheaper, and more scalable than ever before. Organized crime groups, both domestic and transnational, are using generative AI to mimic identities, generate synthetic documentation, and flood our systems with fraudulent claims.

They’re not just stealing from the government; they’re stealing from the American people.The Small Business Administration Inspector General now estimates that nearly $200 billion was stolen from pandemic-era unemployment insurance programs, making it one of the largest fraud losses in U.S. history.

Medicaid, IRS, TANF, CHIP, and disaster relief programs face similar vulnerabilities. We have also seen this firsthand in our work alongside the U.S. Secret Service protecting the USDA SNAP program, which has become a buffet for fraudsters with billions stolen nationwide every month. In fact, in a single day using AI, one fraud ring can file tens of thousands of fake claims across multiple states, most of which will be processed automatically unless flagged.

We’ve reached a turning point. As AI continues to evolve, the scale and sophistication of these attacks will increase rapidly. Just as Moore’s Law predicted that computing power would double every two years, we’re now living through a new kind of exponential growth. Gordon Moore, Intel’s co-founder, originally described the trend in 1965, and it has guided decades of innovation.

I believe we may soon recognize a similar principle for AI that I call “Altman’s Law”: every 180 days, AI capabilities double.If we don’t modernize our defenses with the same pace as technological advancements, we’ll be permanently outmatched.What we desperately need is smarter tools and infrastructure, not more bureaucracy.

That means layering advanced identity verification, not just facial scans or passwords. It means using real-time data, behavioral analytics, and cross-jurisdictional tools that can flag anomalies before money goes out the door. It also means reviving what has already worked: tools like the National Accuracy Clearinghouse, which flagged billions of dollars in duplicate benefit claims across state lines before it was shut down.

AI is a force multiplier, but it can be weaponized more easily than it can be wielded for protection. Right now, criminals are using it better than we are. Until that changes, our most vulnerable systems and the people who depend on them will remain exposed.The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.

Introducing the 2025 Fortune 500, the definitive ranking of the biggest companies in America. Explore this year's list.

Analysis

Phenomenon+
Conflict+
Background+
Impact+
Future+

Related Podcasts

I’m a cybersecurity CEO who advises over 9,000 agencies and Sam Altman is wrong that the AI fraud crisis is coming—it’s already here | Goose Pod | Goose Pod