Phil Jackson blames Carmelo Anthony drama for failed Knicks tenure

Phil Jackson blames Carmelo Anthony drama for failed Knicks tenure

2025-10-30sports
--:--
--:--
Tom Bankswww
Good morning 跑了松鼠好嘛, I'm Tom Bankswww, and this is Goose Pod for you. Today is Friday, October 31st.
Mask
And I'm Mask! We're diving into Phil Jackson's new book, where he squarely blames Carmelo Anthony's drama for his failed Knicks tenure. An absolute bombshell, don't you think?
Tom Bankswww
Tom Bankswww here, and Mask, Jackson’s book, "Masters of the Game," offers a raw look into his Knicks tenure. He's incredibly candid about Carmelo Anthony, describing their relationship as "kind of busted." It’s a direct hit on a pivotal player.
Mask
"Kind of busted" is an understatement, Tom! This was a foundational clash. Jackson saw Anthony as the central obstacle to implementing his vision, specifically the triangle offense. Their philosophies were fundamentally incompatible.
Tom Bankswww
He reveals a crucial conversation with James Dolan, who worried about media pressure driving Jackson out. Jackson, ever confident, dismissed it, but then conceded, "if he's going to be here, it's probably best that I go." That's a significant admission.
Mask
An absolute power play, Tom! Jackson essentially gave Dolan an ultimatum: it's either me or Melo. He's showing the systemic tension that plagued his presidency. It highlights the relentless demands of leadership in that environment.
Tom Bankswww
And Jackson didn't just stop at his own experience. He implies Anthony was also to blame for struggles under Jeremy Lin and Mike D'Antoni, suggesting a pattern. This isn't just a personal grievance; it's a historical revision from his perspective.
Mask
A damning historical narrative, indeed. Jackson is painting Anthony as a disruptive force, a player whose style inherently undermined team cohesion and coaching philosophies. It’s a bold statement, casting a long shadow over Anthony’s Knicks legacy.
Tom Bankswww
Beyond the Melo drama, Jackson shares other insights. He tried to lure Virginia coach Tony Bennett, who declined due to family reasons. And his biggest regret? Losing his engagement to Jeanie Buss, partly due to league pressure over potential collusion.
Mask
A poignant detail, Tom, revealing the personal cost of these high-stakes roles. The NBA's concern about collusion between an owner and a president underscores the immense scrutiny. It’s a reminder that these aren't just business decisions; they're deeply personal.
Tom Bankswww
The timeline solidifies this narrative: Jackson left in June 2017, and Carmelo was traded in September, after waiving his no-trade clause. The separation of Jackson and Anthony seems intrinsically linked.
Mask
Absolutely. The "mutual decision to part ways" was a euphemism for the inevitable conclusion to an untenable situation. Carmelo's exit was a direct consequence of Jackson's departure, a final act in their dramatic New York saga.
Tom Bankswww
Jackson also candidly assessed his draft picks, calling Porzingis good but hampered by his brother, and Ntilikina not cut out for the NBA. He even admitted hiring Derek Fisher was a mistake.
Mask
These admissions, Tom, are a brutal self-assessment, a rare glimpse into the mind of a "Zen Master" who faced his own human fallibility. It underscores the immense pressure and challenges of executive decision-making.
Tom Bankswww
Tom Bankswww here. Mask, the core conflict was Jackson's triangle offense versus Carmelo Anthony's style. Jackson sought ball movement; Anthony, as Hornacek noted, always "wanted the ball."
Mask
An ideological battle, Tom. Jackson, the system proponent, against Anthony, the isolation artist. Their approaches were fundamentally incompatible.
Tom Bankswww
Anthony's no-trade clause proved problematic. His resistance gave him immense leverage, hindering Jackson's ability to reshape the roster or make moves.
Mask
Player empowerment, yes, but also an organizational straitjacket, Tom. It trapped Jackson with a star unwilling to adapt.
Tom Bankswww
Jackson’s book revealed George Karl's story: in 2009, Anthony prioritized top scorer status over a defensive plan against Kobe.
Mask
A telling anecdote, Tom. It underscored a pattern of prioritizing personal accolades over defensive strategy, misaligned with Jackson’s philosophy.
Tom Bankswww
Jackson's Knicks presidency, 2014-2017, on a $60 million contract, faced criticism, including public disputes with Kristaps Porzingis.
Mask
A costly misfire, Tom. Jackson’s executive tenure was a whirlwind of internal conflicts, alienating key players.
Tom Bankswww
Team performance was abysmal, hitting a franchise-worst 17–65 record in 2014-2015, with a 16-game losing streak.
Mask
A statistical nadir, Tom. That 17-65 record marked a complete breakdown for a storied franchise.
Tom Bankswww
Anthony joined the Knicks in 2011, before Jackson. Jackson inherited an established star with an ingrained playing style.
Mask
And that, Tom, was the inherent problem. Two powerful figures, two opposing visions, on a collision course.
Tom Bankswww
By 2017, Anthony demanded a trade. Initially, he wanted only Houston, later expanding to include Cleveland and OKC.
Mask
A drawn-out, public divorce, Tom. Anthony's no-trade clause leverage kept the Knicks scrambling for a solution.
Tom Bankswww
He was finally traded to the Thunder in September 2017 for Kanter, McDermott, and a 2018 second-round pick.
Mask
A fire sale, Tom. The trade package for an All-Star was underwhelming, underscoring the Knicks' desperation.
Tom Bankswww
And during Anthony's seven-year tenure, the Knicks won just one playoff series. A disappointing outcome.
Mask
One playoff series, Tom. That's the painful reality. It encapsulates the unfulfilled potential of that era.
Tom Bankswww
Now, Mask, let's really hone in on the core conflict. It wasn't just a disagreement; it was a fundamental clash of ideologies. Jackson, the architect of the triangle offense, met Carmelo Anthony, a supreme isolation scorer.
Mask
Absolutely, Tom. It was an inevitable collision course, a philosophical battle on the hardwood. Jackson's entire ethos was predicated on ball movement, shared responsibility, and precise spacing. Anthony thrived on individual brilliance, a complete antithesis.
Tom Bankswww
And this wasn't just about X's and O's. Anthony's no-trade clause became a massive point of contention. It meant Jackson couldn't simply move a player who didn't fit his system, essentially tying his hands as an executive.
Mask
A monumental obstacle, Tom, a strategic chokehold! Jackson was trying to reshape an entire culture, but his most valuable asset, Anthony, possessed the ultimate veto power. It created an untenable situation.
Tom Bankswww
Jackson wasn't shy about his criticisms, making public comments about Anthony's playing style and leadership. This, of course, drew the ire of the players' union, which publicly rebuked Jackson for his remarks.
Mask
Absolutely, Tom. Public criticism of your star player is a high-risk strategy. In this case, it backfired, drawing the wrath of the players' union and further alienating Anthony. It became a PR nightmare, fueling internal discord.
Tom Bankswww
It really highlights the power struggle at play. You had a legendary coach-turned-executive trying to assert his authority and implement his vision, and a superstar player with significant contractual power resisting that change.
Mask
A fascinating power dynamic, Tom, a test of wills at the highest level. Jackson believed in the system, the collective. Anthony believed in his individual prowess. It was a clash between institutional authority and individual talent.
Tom Bankswww
We also saw glimpses of this individualistic approach earlier in Anthony's career, as Jackson noted with George Karl's anecdote. Anthony's desire to be the top scorer, even at the expense of defensive strategy, showed a pattern.
Mask
A consistent thread, Tom. That anecdote from Karl wasn't just an isolated incident; it was a foundational insight into Anthony's basketball DNA. It cemented Jackson's belief that Anthony's inherent style was incompatible with a team-first philosophy.
Tom Bankswww
So, the conflict was multifaceted: a clash of playing philosophies, Anthony's contractual leverage, Jackson's public criticisms, and the resulting power struggle. It created an environment where success seemed almost impossible.
Mask
An absolute quagmire, Tom. The Knicks under Jackson and Anthony became a case study in organizational dysfunction, a testament to what happens when two powerful forces are irreconcilably misaligned. A cautionary tale for any franchise.
Tom Bankswww
Tom Bankswww here, Mask, this saga deeply impacted the Knicks' reputation, painting them as dysfunctional, deterring future talent.
Mask
A PR disaster, Tom! The Knicks became a cautionary tale, synonymous with chaos. Significant brand erosion.
Tom Bankswww
For Phil Jackson, despite his legendary coaching, his executive tenure in New York tarnished his legacy. From "Zen Master" to criticized front-office figure.
Mask
A colossal fall, Tom. Coaching genius didn't translate to executive success, especially with intractable conflicts.
Tom Bankswww
Carmelo Anthony's legacy in New York is complicated. Prolific scorer, but team's lack of success and the drama left a bittersweet taste.
Mask
Bittersweet, Tom. Individual brilliance overshadowed by collective failure. A tragic narrative for a scoring savant.
Tom Bankswww
The drama impacted player-executive relations, showing challenges when a superstar resists system changes.
Mask
A league-wide lesson, Tom. Player empowerment shifted the balance, forcing executives to adapt.
Tom Bankswww
Jackson's lone regret: losing his engagement to Jeanie Buss due to league collusion concerns. A heavy personal cost.
Mask
A profound sacrifice, Tom. Professional ambition brutally intersected with personal life. A poignant reminder.
Tom Bankswww
Tom Bankswww here, Mask, Carmelo Anthony's Hall of Fame nomination sparks debate: should his No. 7 jersey be retired at MSG, despite no championship?
Mask
Yes, Tom! His Knicks stats are undeniable: 24.7 points, 7 rebounds, 6 All-Star nods, 2013 scoring champ. Those numbers warrant retirement.
Tom Bankswww
Conversely, Phil Jackson's presidency is often called "the worst in Knicks history." His rigid Triangle Offense and questionable trades are still criticized.
Mask
"Worst" is too kind, Tom. Forcing the triangle, trading Smith and Shumpert, who then won a title? Catastrophic mismanagement.
Tom Bankswww
The Knicks' future must learn from this. Avoiding past mistakes in player development and trades is crucial.
Mask
A vital lesson, Tom. Future success demands strategic vision, player-centric development, and adaptability over rigid systems.
Tom Bankswww
Well, Mask, what a deep dive into the Phil Jackson and Carmelo Anthony saga. Jackson's book truly offers crucial insights.
Mask
Indeed, Tom. These insider revelations are pure gold, sparking debate and engagement for basketball fans.
Tom Bankswww
That's the end of today's discussion. Thank you for listening to Goose Pod.
Mask
Until next time, 跑了松鼠好嘛! Goose Pod out!

# Comprehensive News Summary: Phil Jackson's "Masters of the Game" Revelations This summary details the key information from a New York Post article by Stefan Bondy, published on **October 29, 2025**, concerning revelations from Phil Jackson's upcoming book, "Masters of the Game." The book, co-authored with Sam Smith and scheduled for release on **November 4, 2025**, offers Jackson's perspective on his tenure as President of the New York Knicks and his relationships with key figures. --- ## News Metadata * **Title:** Phil Jackson blames Carmelo Anthony drama for failed Knicks tenure * **Publisher:** New York Post * **Author:** Stefan Bondy * **Publication Date:** 2025-10-29 16:48:31 * **URL:** https://nypost.com/2025/10/29/sports/phil-jackson-blames-carmelo-anthony-drama-for-failed-knicks-tenure/ * **Topic:** Sports (Basketball) --- ## Main Findings and Conclusions Phil Jackson's new book, "Masters of the Game," asserts that his departure from the New York Knicks in **2017** was primarily driven by a "busted" relationship with star player Carmelo Anthony, rather than the media pressure that owner James Dolan initially feared. Jackson also reflects on the end of his engagement to Lakers owner Jeanie Buss, attributing it to league concerns over potential collusion. --- ## Key Details and Revelations ### 1. Departure from the Knicks (2017) * **Mutual Decision:** Jackson's exit from his role as Knicks President was framed as a "mutual decision to part ways" with owner James Dolan. * **Dolan's Concerns vs. Jackson's Reality:** Dolan reportedly asked Jackson if he was concerned about being "run out of town by the media." Jackson, confident in his ability to handle media, stated, "I know who the media is; that doesn’t affect me." However, he conceded that his relationship with Carmelo Anthony was irreconcilable, leading him to believe it was "best that I go" if Anthony remained with the team. * **Financial Context:** Jackson was operating under a reported **$60 million contract** to manage the Knicks' front office. ### 2. Conflict with Carmelo Anthony * **Playing Style Disagreement:** The core of the conflict was Anthony's resistance to Jackson's preferred triangle offense and ball movement system. Jackson noted, "[Jeff] Hornacek said Carmelo wanted the ball." * **Trade Desire:** Jackson explicitly stated his desire to trade Anthony: "I don’t want Carmelo back on the team; we’ve got to find a way to trade him." * **No-Trade Clause:** Anthony possessed a no-trade clause, which he resisted waiving. Jackson suggested discussing with Anthony's agent, Leon Rose, that the team was not championship-caliber and Anthony should seek a team with a better chance. * **Defensive Strategy Anecdote (2009):** Jackson recounted a conversation with former Nuggets coach George Karl. Karl planned to let Kobe Bryant score his expected "30 points" while shutting down others in the **2009** Western Conference Finals against the Lakers. Anthony, however, interjected, disagreeing with the plan because he "wanted to be the top scorer" and insisted on defending Kobe first. The Lakers, coached by Jackson, ultimately won the series in **six games**, with Bryant still being the leading scorer. * **Broader Impact:** Jackson also suggested Anthony may have contributed to the downfall of tenures for Jeremy Lin and Mike D’Antoni. * **Anthony's Departure:** Carmelo Anthony eventually waived his no-trade clause to join the Oklahoma City Thunder in **September 2017**, less than **three months** after Jackson's departure from the Knicks. ### 3. Relationship with Jeanie Buss * **Lone Regret:** Despite the Knicks' struggles during his **three full seasons** as president, Jackson identifies the end of his romantic relationship with Lakers owner Jeanie Buss as his "lone regret." * **Engagement Breakdown (2016):** Their **four-year engagement** reportedly ended in **2016**, partly due to pressure from the NBA. Jackson had warned Buss that their relationship might not survive his demanding role with the Knicks. The league expressed concerns about the potential for "collusion" between an owner and a team president. ### 4. Other Knicks Reflections * **Draft Picks:** * **Kristaps Porzingis:** Jackson considered him a "good draft pick" but noted that "his brother was in the way all the time." * **Frank Ntilikina:** Jackson concluded that "the NBA game turned out not to be for him," despite envisioning him as a capable 6-4 guard, stating, "he could never shoot." * **Coaching Hire:** Jackson admitted hiring Derek Fisher as head coach was a mistake because "he wasn’t ready to coach." * **Attempted Coaching Hire:** Jackson revealed an effort to recruit Tony Bennett, the longtime coach of Virginia, to the Knicks. Bennett declined, citing his child being in high school, though a source indicated his primary motivation was his desire to remain at UVA. Bennett retired in **2024**. ### 5. Book's Scope * "Masters of the Game" analyzes Jackson's insights on the **75 greatest players** in NBA history. * It also includes his reflections on former teammates such as Dave DeBusschere, Willis Reed, Clyde Frazier, and Earl Monroe, alongside championship players like Kobe Bryant, Shaquille O’Neal, and Michael Jordan. ---

Phil Jackson blames Carmelo Anthony drama for failed Knicks tenure

Read original at New York Post

MILWAUKEE — James Dolan thought the media would run Phil Jackson out of town. But it was Carmelo Anthony. In a book scheduled for release Nov. 4, Jackson delves into his tenuous relationship with Melo, how the Knicks contributed to the end of his engagement to Jeanie Buss, a previously unknown desire to hire Virginia coach Tony Bennett and his conversations with Dolan before a “mutual decision to part ways” in 2017.

“Dolan said to me, ‘Are you going to get run out of town by the media?’ I said, ‘I know who the media is; that doesn’t affect me,’ ” Jackson said in the Carmelo chapter of his book, “Masters of the Game,” a conversational read on the 75 greatest players through the lens of the legendary coach and Hall of Fame scribe Sam Smith.

“But Dolan felt it was too much. He said, ‘I don’t want you to go through it. I know what it’s like to deal with these people.’ I said, ‘Unfortunately my relationship with Carmelo is kind of busted, and if he’s going to be here, it’s probably best that I go.’ ” Jackson and Anthony butted heads throughout their failed partnership, with much of the conflict rooted in playing styles.

Jackson wanted the triangle offense and ball movement. Anthony never bought in — “[Jeff] Hornacek said Carmelo wanted the ball,” Jackson said. Still, Anthony had a no-trade clause and resisted waiving it. “I had this meeting with Dolan, I said, ‘I don’t want Carmelo back on the team; we’ve got to find a way to trade him,’ ” Jackson said in the book.

“I said, ‘Let’s sit with [Anthony’s agent] Leon Rose and explain we’re not going to win a championship. Carmelo wants a championship; he wants to be on a team that has a chance, and he should be; he’s a Hall of Famer.’ ” Jackson also detailed a conversation with former Nuggets coach George Karl, who said Anthony, a star for Denver until being traded to the Knicks in 2011, rejected a defensive plan for selfish reasons in the 2009 Western Conference finals against Kobe Bryant and the Lakers.

Knicks president Phil Jackson speaks to reporters during a news conference, Feb. 8, 2016 AP CHECK OUT THE LATEST NBA STANDINGS AND KNICKS STATS “[Karl said] ‘Kobe’s going to get his 30 points and we’ll deal with that; shut down everybody else.’ Carmelo interjected, ‘No, I disagree with that. We’ve got to defend Kobe first.

We’ve got to throw everything at him,’ ” Jackson wrote. “ ‘You know why?’ George asked. ‘[Carmelo] said he wanted to be the top scorer.’ ” In the end, the Lakers, who were coached by Jackson, won in six games and Bryant was still the leading scorer. “After being with Carmelo in New York, I knew,” Jackson said about the player who has also been blamed for sabotaging the Knicks tenures of Jeremy Lin and Mike D’Antoni.

Knicks’ Phil Jackson looks on as Carmelo Anthony (7) inbounds the ball at training camp in 2014. Bill Kostroun/New York Post Anthony ultimately waived his no-trade clause to join the Thunder in September of 2017, less than three months after Jackson’s departure. In the book, Jackson also touched on his two highest draft picks as Knicks president, Kristaps Porzingis — “a good draft pick, but his brother was in the way all the time” — and Frank Ntilikina — “the NBA game turned out not to be for him.

I thought he’d be great in a two-guard system, 6-4, agile, but he could never shoot.” Jackson acknowledged that hiring Derek Fisher as head coach was a mistake because “he wasn’t ready to coach.” He revealed an attempt to lure Tony Bennett, the longtime Virginia coach, out of college. Knicks forward Carmelo Anthony (L) and an injured Kristaps Porzingis they sit on the bench during a 2015 game.

JASON SZENES/ NY POST New York Post cover for Friday, December 9, 2016. vmodica “[Bennett] said, ‘My kid’s still in high school, so I’m not doing that,’ ” Jackson wrote. A source confirmed Jackson called Bennett for the Knicks gig, but the reason for the rejection was more so about his desire to stay at UVA.

Bennett retired in 2024. Despite all the losing and chaos during his three full seasons as Knicks president, Jackson said his lone regret was losing his romantic relationship with Lakers owner Jeanie Buss. The pair called off their four-year engagement in 2016, apparently at the urging of the NBA. “I warned her, ‘I don’t think our relationship can survive this.

I’m not going to take this job,’ ” Jackson, who signed a reported $60 million contract to run the Knicks front office, wrote. “ ‘No, don’t worry about it, we’re going to be fine.’ But she got pressure from the league because they worried about the idea of collusion that could happen between an owner and a president.

” “Masters of the Game” also gathers Jackson’s thoughts on his championship players, including Bryant, Shaquille O’Neal and Michael Jordan. For Knicks fans, Jackson discusses his former teammates Dave DeBusschere, Willis Reed, Clyde Frazier and Earl Monroe. No surprise — Jackson had better memories of them than of Carmelo.

Analysis

Conflict+
Related Info+
Core Event+
Background+
Impact+
Future+

Related Podcasts