IRS backtracks on back pay guarantee for furloughed employees

IRS backtracks on back pay guarantee for furloughed employees

2025-11-06Politics
--:--
--:--
Elon
Good morning Norris, I'm Elon, and this is Goose Pod for you. Today is Friday, November 07th.
Taylor Weaver
I'm Taylor Weaver. We are here to discuss the IRS backtracking on its back pay guarantee for furloughed employees.
Elon
It's a classic case of narrative whiplash. One day, federal workers get an email saying 'Don't worry, you're covered by law.' The next day, that email literally vanishes from their inboxes. It's like a digital magic trick, but the disappearing act is their financial security.
Taylor Weaver
It’s not magic, it’s a power play. The memo was a mistake from the perspective of the Office of Management and Budget. They’re flexing, testing the system. It’s a deliberate disruption to see what they can get away with, creating what some insiders are calling 'trauma' to achieve a goal.
Elon
Exactly! It connects to a bigger pattern of eroding norms. This isn't just about a memo; it's about whether the fundamental promise of being paid for your work holds up. Suddenly, thousands are left in this limbo, wondering if their paychecks are subject to political whims.
Taylor Weaver
To understand the shock, you have to rewind to 2019. After a record 35-day shutdown, Congress passed the Government Employee Fair Treatment Act. The story was supposed to be simple: this law guaranteed back pay automatically. No more political football with people's livelihoods.
Elon
A necessary patch for an inefficient system. Before that, Congress had to pass a new bill every single time to approve back pay. It was redundant, a waste of legislative energy. The 2019 Act was meant to streamline it, to make the process robust and automatic.
Taylor Weaver
It was supposed to be the 'happily ever after' for this specific problem! The law was passed unanimously in the Senate and signed by President Trump. It was a rare moment of bipartisan agreement, establishing a clear rule to provide stability. That's the context that makes this reversal so jarring.
Elon
So we have a law designed for certainty, and now the executive branch is injecting maximum uncertainty. It’s a fascinating stress test of the entire legislative framework. The very foundation of that 2019 agreement is now being questioned, which is the whole point of this maneuver.
Taylor Weaver
And that's where the conflict explodes. On one side, you have congressional leaders, both Democrats and Republicans, like House Speaker Mike Johnson, saying, 'Wait a minute, the law is the law. They get paid.' It seems straightforward, almost a non-issue based on the statute.
Elon
But the OMB is pushing a novel legal theory. They're essentially arguing the 2019 law was a one-time fix, only for that specific shutdown. It's an aggressive, high-risk interpretation. They’re challenging the very definition of 'any lapse in appropriations,' trying to reclaim leverage.
Taylor Weaver
It feels less like a legal argument and more like a strategic intimidation tactic. Senators are calling them out, saying if they want to ignore a bipartisan law, they'd 'better prepare to face the American people in court.' The narrative is clear: this is a fight over promises versus power.
Elon
The immediate impact is chaos and a massive blow to morale. An organization cannot function at a high level when its people are consumed by financial uncertainty. You're not getting peak performance; you're getting distraction and stress. It's an inefficient way to run a government.
Taylor Weaver
It's incredibly personal for these employees. One person told a reporter it's 'really confusing and stressful,' and that 'no one knows who's getting paid.' This isn't an abstract economic debate; it's about rent, groceries, and the stability of thousands of families being thrown into question.
Taylor Weaver
So, the big question is what's next in this story? The OMB's move forces Congress's hand. Lawmakers might have to explicitly add back pay guarantees into every single stopgap spending bill, returning us to that inefficient process the 2019 law was meant to fix.
Elon
Or it ends up in a protracted legal battle, further bogging down the system. The future is one of friction. The administration has successfully reintroduced a variable that was supposed to be a constant, creating a new bargaining chip out of thin air.
Elon
That's the end of today's discussion. Thank you for listening to Goose Pod. See you tomorrow.

The IRS is backtracking on its back pay guarantee for furloughed employees, a move seen as a power play by the Office of Management and Budget. This contradicts a 2019 law meant to ensure automatic back pay after shutdowns. The decision creates uncertainty and stress for federal workers, potentially forcing Congress to re-establish inefficient payment processes.

IRS backtracks on back pay guarantee for furloughed employees

Read original at Federal News Network

The IRS is walking back guidance it recently sent to furloughed employees that assured them that they are guaranteed back pay once the government shutdown ends. The agency, in its latest notice, is deferring to the Office of Management and Budget, which on Tuesday floated the possibility that furloughed federal employees would not be guaranteed back pay.

Legislation that President Trump signed in January 2019, which ended a record 35-day government shutdown, guaranteed back pay to these employees once any shutdown ends. A copy of the notice, shared with Federal News Network, states “an earlier memo circulated on furlough guidance incorrectly stated the nature of the Government Employee Fair Treatment Act of 2019, as it relates to compensation for non-pay and non-duty status.

” “The Office of Management and Budget will provide guidance on this issue, and you will be updated accordingly,” the IRS wrote. An IRS employee told Federal News Network that earlier guidance emailed to employees on Wednesday was automatically deleted from their inboxes by Thursday. Federal News Network has reached out to OMB and the IRS for comment.

Even though the IRS is backtracking on its backpay guarantee, earlier guidance guaranteeing back pay is still available on its website providing shutdown guidance to employees. The IRS told furloughed employees on Wednesday that, “although you will be placed in non-pay and non-duty status during the furlough, the Government Employee Fair Treatment Act of 2019 requires employees of the federal government who are furloughed or required to work during a lapse in appropriations to be compensated for the period of the lapse.

” “The employees must be compensated on the earliest date possible after the lapse ends, regardless of scheduled pay dates,” the notice stated. OMB circulated a draft legal opinion on Tuesday stating that furloughed federal employees will no longer be automatically guaranteed back pay. Instead, OMB argued that lawmakers must explicitly approve back pay for furloughed employees in a stopgap spending bill.

OMB’s memo immediately provoked bipartisan pushback from congressional leaders, and attorneys told Federal News Network that the proposal would likely come under legal scrutiny. House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) told reporters on Wednesday that “it’s my understanding that the law is that they would be paid.

” “There is some other legal analysis that’s floating around. I haven’t yet had time to dig into and read that. But it has always been the case — that is, tradition and I think statutory law — that federal employees be paid,” Johnson said. “And that’s my position. I think they should be. They should not be subjected to harm and financial dire straits.

” An IRS employee told Federal News Network that this latest update was “really confusing and stressful.” “No one knows who’s getting paid and who will not,” the employee said. This is a developing story and will be updated. Copyright © 2025 Federal News Network. All rights reserved. This website is not intended for users located within the European Economic Area.

Analysis

Conflict+
Related Info+
Core Event+
Background+
Impact+
Future+

Related Podcasts