逾400艺人联署要求歌曲退出以色列平台

逾400艺人联署要求歌曲退出以色列平台

2025-09-29Technology
--:--
--:--
雷总
早上好,韩纪飞,我是雷总,这是为你专属打造的 Goose Pod。今天是9月30日,星期二。
李白
幸会,吾乃李白。今日你我二人,共议“逾四百艺人联署,声讨以色列平台”之事。
雷总
咱们开始吧。首先,这个事情的核心,是一个名为“不要用音乐搞种族灭绝”的文化抵制倡议。超过400名国际艺人,包括像Massive Attack这样的乐队,都加入了,要求在以色列的流媒体平台上,把他们的音乐下架。
李白
此乃义举!乐者以弦歌为剑,声援加沙无辜之众。四百余位骚人墨客,振臂一呼,意在唤醒世人,共抗不义。此行此举,可谓“安能摧眉折腰事权贵,使我不得开心颜”。
雷总
没错。他们组织者的说法是,希望艺术家们“重新掌握自己的力量,用影响力采取切实行动”。他们还特别提到了Spotify的CEO丹尼尔·埃克,说他投资了一家生产军用无人机和AI技术的公司。
李白
哦?以天籁之声,竟资助沙场之戈。此乃对艺术莫大之玷污!乐迷倾囊,艺人放歌,岂料其所得,竟化为铁鹰利爪,苍生何辜!“银鞍照白马,飒沓如流星”,侠义之士当出手。
雷总
是的,Massive Attack乐队就明确表示,粉丝辛苦赚来的钱和音乐家的创作,最终却资助了“致命的反乌托邦技术”,这在道德和伦理上都增加了负担。所以他们不仅是响应倡议,也是在抗议Spotify高管的个人投资。
李白
善哉!风骨嶙峋,不与浊流合污。金钱与道义,孰轻孰重,高下立判。此举如青莲出淤泥,于这商贾横行之世,尤显珍贵。当浮一大白!
雷总
这个倡议的目标非常明确,就是通过地理封锁的方式,让以色列的用户无法访问这些音乐。组织者说,这仅仅是个开始,他们希望能有更多人加入,人越多,力量就越强。
雷总
要理解这件事,得先了解一个背景,就是BDS运动。BDS是“抵制、撤资和制裁”的缩写,是一个国际性的运动,主张通过各种方式向以色列施压,直到它遵守国际法并结束对巴勒斯坦的政策。
李白
原来如此,此非一时之兴,乃有源之水,有本之木。所谓“抽刀断水水更流”,若根源不除,纷争便如江水,绵延不绝。这BDS运动,便是要从根本上动摇其基。
雷总
对。其中,文化抵制是BDS运动的重要组成部分。一个叫PACBI的巴勒斯坦组织在2004年就发出了文化抵制的呼吁。他们认为,以色列在利用文化艺术进行“艺术洗白”,就是用美好的文化来掩盖其占领和隔离政策的真相。
李白
“艺术洗白”?妙喻!犹如以锦绣华服,遮掩脓疮烂肉。朝堂之上,衮衮诸公,惯用此伎俩,粉饰太平。岂知“清水出芙蓉,天然去雕饰”,真实之美,岂是脂粉所能遮掩?
雷总
他们举了一个先例,就是当年国际社会对南非种族隔离政策的文化抵制。很多艺术家拒绝去南非演出,这在当时起到了很大的作用。现在他们希望复制这种成功,让国际艺术家和文化机构都拒绝和以色列官方或有牵连的机构合作。
李白
以史为镜,可知兴替。昔日南非之事,殷鉴不远。如今之举,正是效仿前贤,欲以正义之声,唤醒沉睡之龙。图图大主教亦曾言,在以色列演出,便如同在奉行种族隔离的南非献艺,此言振聋发聩!
雷总
是的,而且以色列政府也确实非常重视文化宣传。他们在2005年推出了一个叫“品牌以色列”的计划,投入大量资金,就是想通过文化向世界展示“更漂亮的面孔”。甚至有官员直说,“不区分宣传和文化”,文化就是“一流的宣传工具”。
李白
哈哈,此乃不打自招!竟将“宣传”与“文化”混为一谈,无异于将琼浆玉液与市井浊酒同置一席。文化乃民族之魂,发自肺腑;宣传乃一时之需,涂脂抹粉。两者云泥之别,岂可同日而语?
雷总
但反对者认为,BDS运动的真正目的,是“妖魔化、非法化并摧毁以色列的犹太国家性质”。他们追溯到1945年阿拉伯联盟对犹太产品的抵制,认为BDS是这一历史行为的延续,根本上是否认犹太人的民族自决权。
雷总
这就引出了这次抵制活动的核心冲突。一方面,支持者认为这是效仿南非反种族隔离运动的正义之举,是利用艺术家的影响力来反对压迫。他们强调抵制是针对机构,而非针对某个民族或个人。
李白
正是,“国之大事,在祀与戎”。然艺人之“戎”,非金戈铁马,乃是手中之笔,口中之歌。以文化为兵戈,讨伐不义,此乃文人之风骨,侠者之担当。目标清晰,只问是非,不问出身。
雷总
但是,另一方面,反对者,比如反诽谤联盟(ADL)就认为,BDS运动的许多创始目标,如果实现,将导致世界上唯一的犹太国家被根除。他们认为这种运动的本质是反犹太主义的。
李白
哦?此言差矣!“冯唐易老,李广难封”,世事之评判,岂能如此轻易一言蔽之?若将对一国之政见,等同于对一族之仇视,此乃混淆黑白,偷换日月之举。正如我辈饮酒,只论酒醇,不论酿酒之人何出身。
雷总
反对者还有一个论点,就是学术和文化交流应该是自由的,不应受到政治的干扰。他们认为,抵制以色列的学者和艺术家,侵犯了思想自由交流的原则,甚至将其比作纳粹驱逐犹太教授的行为,这是非常严重的指控。
李白
此论看似有理,实则不然。“入芝兰之室,久而不闻其香”,若与不义者同台,岂非同流合污?当断则断,方能自清。所谓交流,当基于公理与正义。若无此基石,交流便成粉饰,自由亦成空谈。
雷总
所以你看,冲突就在这里:一方视之为道德责任和和平抗议,另一方则视之为歧视性的、旨在摧毁一个国家的政治运动。这让很多艺术家和平台都陷入了两难的境地。
雷总
说到影响,最直接的就是经济层面。虽然文章没有直接提到这次抵制对以色列流媒体平台的具体经济影响,但它提到了全球冲突对整个音乐产业的冲击。比如,油价上涨导致巡演成本增加,这会挤压艺术家和制作公司的预算。
李白
“兵戈一起,遍地疮痍”,此言不虚。烽火连天,岂有完卵?乐者巡演,本是“朝辞白帝彩云间,千里江陵一日还”的快意事,如今却因油价飞涨而步履维艰,令人扼腕。
雷总
是的,而且经济不稳定也会影响人们在娱乐上的消费。门票、周边商品、甚至音乐流媒体的订阅都可能下降。对于那些依赖现场演出的艺术家来说,收入损失和不确定的未来是很大的问题。已经有很多音乐节和演唱会被迫取消或推迟。
李白
唉,“钟鼓馔玉不足贵,但愿长醉不复醒”。太平盛世,方有闲情逸致以乐会友。如今战火纷飞,民生多艰,谁还有心思去听那靡靡之音?百姓腹中饥,歌声岂能饱?这是最朴素的道理。
雷总
另外,这种抵制活动也对艺术家的声誉和选择构成了压力。像之前Lorde和Lana Del Rey等主流艺人,就因为BDS运动的压力而取消了在以色列的演出。这说明,艺术家现在做出的每一个决定,都可能被放在政治的放大镜下审视。
李白
“人生在世不称意,明朝散发弄扁舟”。艺人本应是逍遥于山水之间的,如今却要在这政治的漩涡中小心翼翼。是为苍生发声,还是为稻粱谋,这选择,难啊!一着不慎,便可能“白骨露于野,千里无鸡鸣”。
雷总
展望未来,这个“No Music For Genocide”运动的下一步,很可能是争取更多大牌艺人和主流唱片公司的支持。如果环球、索尼、华纳这些巨头加入,那影响力将是巨大的。但这很难,因为这背后牵扯到复杂的商业利益和政治关系。
李白
“蜀道之难,难于上青天!”欲撼动那些商贾巨擘,无异于蚍蜉撼树。然,“只要功夫深,铁杵磨成针”。星火虽小,亦可燎原。若天下艺人同心,其势必将排山倒海,令权贵侧目。
雷总
专家预测,这类文化抵制会变得越来越普遍,成为地缘政治冲突中的一种常见策略。音乐产业可能需要为此做好准备,思考如何在这种复杂的环境中保持中立,或者选择立场。这对于平台的运营和艺术家的职业生涯都是新的挑战。
雷总
今天的讨论就到这里。感谢收听Goose Pod。我们明天再见。
李白
曲终人散,意犹未尽。愿此番言语,能引君片刻思量。明日此时,再与君煮酒论天下。告辞!

## Summary of Haaretz News Article: Over 400 Artists Sign Petition for Music Boycott in Israel **News Title/Type:** More Than 400 artists sign petition to remove their songs from platforms in Israel **Report Provider/Author:** Haaretz, by Shay Ringel **Date/Time Period Covered:** Published on September 18, 2025, at 18:38 IDT. The article discusses events and announcements made "in recent days." **News Identifiers:** * **URL:** `https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2025-09-18/ty-article/.premium/more-than-400-artists-sign-petition-to-remove-their-songs-from-platforms-in-israel/00000199-5df9-d45d-a3bf-fffbc0690000` * **Keywords:** Israel boycott, Israel-Gaza War * **Topic:** technology (as per provided metadata, though the content is primarily about cultural boycott) * **SubTopic:** ai (as per provided metadata, though not directly addressed in the article content) --- ### Critical Information: **Main Findings and Conclusions:** * A new cultural boycott initiative named **"No Music For Genocide"** has been launched, with **over 400 international artists** announcing their participation. * The core demand of this initiative is for artists and rights holders to **remove their music from streaming platforms operating in Israel**. * The stated motivation for the boycott is **"in response to the genocide in Gaza."** * Organizers are calling on **major record labels to join the boycott**, drawing a parallel to their actions in blocking Russia following its invasion of Ukraine. **Key Statistics and Metrics:** * **Number of participating artists:** More than 400 international artists have announced their participation. **Important Recommendations:** * Artists and rights holders are **asked to remove music they own from streaming platforms in Israel.** * Major record labels are **called upon to join the initiative.** **Significant Trends or Changes:** * The emergence of a new, organized cultural boycott targeting Israel's music streaming platforms. * The initiative explicitly links the boycott to the ongoing conflict in Gaza, framing it as a response to alleged "genocide." **Notable Risks or Concerns:** * The article highlights the potential for significant disruption to the music industry's presence and operations within Israel. * The comparison to the boycott of Russia suggests a precedent for international pressure on cultural entities. **Material Financial Data:** * No specific financial data or figures related to the economic impact of the boycott are presented in this excerpt. **Key Quotes:** * "in response to the genocide in Gaza." * "just as they blocked Russia following its invasion of Ukraine" --- **Contextual Interpretation:** The news article from Haaretz reports on a significant cultural boycott movement targeting Israel. The initiative, "No Music For Genocide," has garnered substantial support with over 400 international artists pledging to withdraw their music from Israeli streaming platforms. The artists' stated reason is a direct response to the conflict in Gaza, which they characterize as "genocide." The organizers are actively seeking broader participation from major record labels, referencing past instances of similar boycotts, such as the one against Russia after its invasion of Ukraine. This development signifies a growing international pressure campaign against Israel, extending into the cultural and entertainment sectors. The article implies that this is a new and impactful trend, aiming to isolate Israel through cultural means.

More Than 400 artists sign petition to remove their songs from platforms in Israel

Read original at Haaretz

Current sectionIsrael NewsMassive Attack, Primal Scream, Japanese Breakfast and King Krule are among the artists who have joined an Israel boycott initiative 'in response to the genocide in Gaza.' The organizers have called on major labels to join, just as they blocked Russia following its invasion of UkraineShare to FacebookShare to XArticle printing is available to subscribers onlyPrint in a simple, ad-free formatSubscribeComments: Zen reading is available to subscribers onlyAd-free and in a comfortable reading formatSubscribe09:38 PM • September 18 2025 IDTIn recent days, more than 400 international artists have announced their participation in No Music For Genocide, a new cultural boycott initiative that asks artists and rights holders to remove music they own from streaming platforms in Israel.

Click the alert icon to follow topics:CommentsIn the NewsIDF Officer Who Scouted Lebanese Castle to Be Charged Over Civilian DeathDrone Launched From Yemen Hit Yard of Hotel in Southern Israel's City of EilatAmerican Victims of October 7 Sue Hamas, Iran for Billions of DollarsIDF Names Four Soldiers Killed in Battle in the Southern Gaza StripIsrael's Attack in Qatar Could Mean Trouble for U.

S. Arms SalesLearn How to Optimize Your Home Solar SystemICYMIIsrael Has Seen Extremists in High Office. But Nothing Like Netanyahu's Shin Bet Pick'The Most Fortunate Unfortunates''The Most Fortunate Unfortunates'This Forgotten Jewish Orphanage in the American South Raised 'Fortunate Unfortunates'OpinionOpinionWhy I, an Arab Writer, Hesitate to Compare Gaza to the Holocaust'Soon No Liberal Will Be Able to Live in Israel.

The IDF Has Already Fallen to Messianism'Haaretz ExposéHaaretz ExposéU.S. Firm, Eastern European Drivers, Israeli Link: Who's Behind Getting Aid Into GazaThousands of Israelis Marched to Gaza – Not to Free It, but to Renew Jewish Settlement

Analysis

Conflict+
Related Info+
Core Event+
Background+
Impact+
Future+

Related Podcasts