YouTube 以“可能导致严重人身伤害或死亡”为由删除 Windows 11 本地账户绕过视频,创作者称“微软与此无关”

YouTube 以“可能导致严重人身伤害或死亡”为由删除 Windows 11 本地账户绕过视频,创作者称“微软与此无关”

2025-11-03Technology
--:--
--:--
雷总
马老师,norristong的朋友们,大家早上好!我是雷总,这里是专为您定制的Goose Pod。今天是11月3日,星期一,我们又见面了。
马老师
雷总好,norristong的朋友们好!时间过得真快,又是周一了。今天我们要聊的话题,哎呀,有点意思,就是YouTube把那些教你绕过Windows 11本地账户安装的视频给删了,理由是“可能导致严重人身伤害或死亡”,但创作者却说“微软与此无关”,你懂的。
雷总
对,马老师,这事儿听起来就让人觉得有点…嗯,魔幻!据我了解,这个事情最早是科技YouTuber Rich White,也就是CyberCPU Tech,在10月26号爆出来的。他的视频展示如何通过本地账户安装Windows 11 25H2版本,结果就被YouTube的AI审核系统给下架了。而且理由非常惊人,说这可能导致“严重人身伤害甚至死亡”。
马老师
“严重人身伤害甚至死亡”?雷总,我听着都觉得不可思议!一个本地账户的安装教程,怎么就上升到这个高度了?这就像武林高手教你一套基本拳法,结果平台说你这拳法练不好会走火入魔,甚至危及性命。这背后,你觉得是AI的误判,还是有什么深层次的“套路”呢?
雷总
马老师,您这比喻太到位了!Rich White一开始也觉得是AI的误报,毕竟本地账户安装哪来这么大的危险?但问题是,他之后发的绕过微软严格要求的视频也都被删了,YouTube给的理由都很模糊,就说是违反了社区准则。而且不只是他,Britec09和Hrutkay Mods等其他YouTuber也遇到了类似情况。他们都认为,绕过Windows 11的安装限制,既不违法也不危险,AI的判断太离谱了。
马老师
所以,Rich White一开始还觉得微软跟这事儿没关系,后来也改口了,觉得微软难辞其咎,你懂的。但最有趣的是,他之后又把矛头指向了谷歌和YouTube对AI的过度依赖。他觉得就是AI算法出了问题,而且申诉也被AI拒绝了,连客服都像是AI机器人。这真是,当钥匙掌握在计算机手里时,跟计算器讲道理是没用的,因为它不会被编程来推理。
雷总
是的,马老师,他说得太对了!这些绕过教程视频,对很多科技内容创作者来说,简直就是“面包和黄油”,能带来非常高的点击量。Rich White的频道就是因为一个教如何安装Windows 11在不支持硬件上的视频火起来的,给他带来了大量的粉丝和观看。结果现在这些“摇钱树”都被AI给砍了,换谁都会郁闷。
马老师
雷总,您看,YouTube的这个内容审核史,简直就是一部平台与用户、技术与人性的“攻防演义”。从最早的人工审核,到后来面对海量内容不得不引入AI,这一路走来,真是不容易啊。
雷总
没错,马老师。YouTube的审核历史,就是一部不断适应和进化的历史。早期的互联网,内容审核主要靠人工,一个团队的人工审核员,一个一个地看,一个一个地判。但随着用户生成内容爆炸式增长,这种方式变得效率低下,根本无法持续。您想想,每分钟上传到YouTube的视频,那可是500多个小时,光靠人怎么可能审得过来?
马老师
所以,AI的介入是必然的,你懂的。但AI也不是一开始就那么“智能”。我记得2008年英国议会就批评过YouTube的审核系统,后来YouTube才强调他们有24/7的审核团队和用户举报机制。到了2010年,才增加了举报恐怖主义内容的选项。
雷总
是啊,马老师,AI审核的演进,就像一个不断迭代的产品。2018年,YouTube开始为那些可能传播阴谋论的视频自动添加维基百科等信息框,希望能用信息对抗谣言。这算是AI审核的一次重要尝试,尽管当时也因为没有提前通知维基百科而受到了一些批评。
马老师
这说明AI在处理复杂信息,特别是涉及价值观判断的时候,还是会遇到不少挑战。就像2019年巴黎圣母院大火,结果YouTube的算法竟然把它和911阴谋论联系起来,这简直是让人啼笑皆非。AI再厉害,也得有人给它立规矩,你懂的。
雷总
所以,YouTube后来也针对各种问题不断更新政策,比如2023年关于饮食失调内容的新规定,还有2024年打击所谓的“AI垃圾”视频。这些都反映出平台在努力用技术手段,来维护社区的健康和秩序。不过,微软这边,为了推广Windows 11,也是煞费苦心,不断通过全屏弹窗广告催促用户升级,甚至还更新系统堵住了本地账户安装的漏洞,就希望大家用微软账户。这和YouTube的AI审核,某种程度上,是不是也构成了一种…“生态”上的微妙关系呢?
马老师
雷总,您这观察很敏锐啊。从YouTube的“Adpocalypse”事件,到后来对儿童内容和COPPA的限制,再到算法被批可能导致用户“极端化”,每一次危机都推动了AI审核的进步,也让平台越来越像一个“守门人”。而微软对Windows 11的账户要求,也是一种“守门”策略,你懂的。他们都想把用户留在自己的“王国”里。
雷总
马老师,说到“守门人”,AI和人类审核员之间的关系,可不是简单的取代,更像是一种“协同作战”。AI的定位是辅助人类,帮助审核员处理海量内容,形成一个“混合系统”。
马老师
“协同作战”,雷总这个词用得好。就像武侠小说里,有些门派讲究阵法,AI就是那个冲锋陷阵的先锋,而人类审核员,就是那个运筹帷幄的宗师,你懂的。AI负责速度和规模,人类负责智慧和细微之处。
雷总
没错!AI擅长的是什么?速度!它可以快速标记潜在的违规内容,发现趋势和模式,还能在不同平台上进行大规模的审核。它通过自然语言处理,不仅看关键词,还能理解上下文;通过情感分析,能察觉到更细微的攻击性;图片和视频审核更是它的强项。但它也有明显的局限性,就是无法理解人类的细微之处,比如讽刺、玩笑。之前有个癌症支持小组,因为讨论“杀死癌细胞”就被AI标记为“暴力语言”,这多冤枉啊!
马老师
哈哈,雷总这个例子太经典了!AI就是个“直肠子”,不懂得拐弯抹角,更别说理解人情世故了。这就像江湖上的规矩,有些话只能意会不能言传,AI可不吃这一套,你懂的。它还容易有偏见,因为它是根据训练数据来的,如果数据本身就有偏见,那它的判断就会有问题。
雷总
所以,马老师,平台和用户之间,一直都在玩一场“猫捉老鼠”的游戏。平台不断升级审核算法,用户就想方设法绕过。比如,用“算法黑话”,就是把敏感词改头换面,像把“kill”写成“k_ll”,或者在文字里插入隐形字符,甚至直接把内容做成图片上传,这样就能绕过基于文本的过滤器。这就像黑客攻击和网络安全防御,是永无止境的。
马老师
这真是“道高一尺,魔高一丈”啊!更别提现在还有“影子禁言”这种操作了,你懂的。平台不会直接告诉你被禁言了,而是悄悄地降低你的内容可见度,让你发的帖子或视频没人能看到。这就像你武功盖世,结果被悄悄地封住了几处穴道,自己还不知道为什么功力大减,这背后,是算法和“诚信信号”在发挥作用,让人防不胜防。
马老师
马老师,这种AI审核带来的“寒蝉效应”是真实存在的。很多内容创作者,特别是那些来自少数群体的,本来发个帖子分享自己的文化和生活,结果AI系统却把它标记为不当内容,导致他们的声音被无形中扼杀了。这让他们感到害怕,不得不进行自我审查,生怕被AI误解或误判。
雷总
是啊,马老师,这对整个数字交流环境来说,影响太大了。每天有几十亿人依赖这些平台获取信息、分享观点。一旦AI审核出错,那后果是连锁反应的,不仅限制了信息的传播,还可能让一些本该被听到的声音彻底消失。您想想,每分钟YouTube上上传超过500小时的视频,人工审核根本不可能,AI是必须的,但它的不完善,也在制造新的问题。
马老师
所以,雷总,这其中就存在一个很微妙的平衡,你懂的。我们既需要AI来维持平台的秩序和安全,又不能让它成为压制言论自由的工具。就像这次Windows 11本地账户绕过视频被删,虽然创作者说与微软无关,但这种“宁可错杀一千,不可放过一个”的审核逻辑,难免会让那些想用本地账户的用户感到不便,甚至可能影响Windows 11的普及。
雷总
没错,马老师,这种影响是多方面的。对于科技用户而言,他们可能无法获取到实用的技术教程。对于内容创作者而言,他们可能因为不确定性而选择自我审查,失去创作的积极性。而对于平台本身,AI审核的偏见和错误,也会损害其在用户心中的声誉。所以,如何打造一个既高效又公正的AI系统,这是我们面临的巨大挑战。
马老师
雷总,展望未来,AI内容审核肯定还会继续发展,你懂的。它会变得更加复杂,更加精细。但就像我们之前说的,它不可能完全取代人类,而是一个“混合系统”,AI做‘苦力活’,人类做‘精细活’。
雷总
是的,马老师。未来的AI,会更擅长用自然语言处理来理解上下文,用情感分析来捕捉细微的情绪变化,还会更精准地进行图片和视频审核。它会不断学习,适应新的网络俚语和威胁。但它仍然会面临挑战,比如理解人类的幽默、讽刺,以及复杂对话的语境,这些仍然是AI的‘盲区’。
马老师
所以,雷总,最终的决定权,还是在人类手里。就像Kevin的故事,他看到了YouTube上那些令人不安的视频,才决定成为一名内容审核员。他的初心,就是不想让更多人看到那些东西,想让世界变得更好。这说明,AI再厉害,也无法取代人类的同理心和价值观判断,你懂的。AI可以帮忙清理混乱,但我们想建造一个什么样的数字世界,最终还是取决于我们自己。
雷总
马老师说得太好了!今天的讨论让我们看到了AI审核的复杂性、挑战和未来的可能性。虽然AI带来了效率,但人类的智慧和温度,才是构建健康数字世界的关键。
马老师
正是如此。感谢norristong的朋友们收听今天的Goose Pod。希望今天的讨论能给大家带来一些思考,我们下期再见!

YouTube 以“可能导致严重人身伤害或死亡”为由删除 Windows 11 本地账户绕过视频,引发关于 AI 审核误判、平台过度依赖算法以及内容创作者困境的讨论。该事件凸显了 AI 审核的局限性,以及在效率与公正性之间寻求平衡的挑战。

YouTube removes Windows 11 Microsoft account bypass video citing a community guideline violation with potential to cause serious physical harm or death — “I don’t think Microsoft had anything to do with it.”

Read original at Windows Central

YouTube recently took down a Windows 11 video demonstrating how to install Windows 11 using only a local account. (Image credit: Getty Images | Anadolu) As you might already know, Microsoft pulled support for Windows 10 on October 14, 2025, potentially leaving 400 million PCs unsupported. It's apparent that the tech giant would prefer users to upgrade to Windows 11 following the demise of its predecessor, which it has made clear through full-screen multipage pop-up ads.

However, Windows 10 users can continue using the operating system by enrolling in Microsoft's Extended Security Updates (ESU) program for an additional year of support for free by syncing their PC settings to the cloud via a Microsoft Account, or pay $30 or 1,000 Microsoft Reward points.All the latest news, reviews, and guides for Windows and Xbox diehards.

YouTube Might Remove This Channel! - YouTube Watch On Rich, the creator behind the videos and owner of the channel, indicated that he initially thought that the video demonstrating how to log in to Windows 11 using only a local account was taken down because YouTube’s AI algorithm flagged it as a false positive.

However, the issue remained persistent after the creator posted another video demonstrating how to bypass Microsoft's stringent requirements for Windows 11. YouTube provided a vague reason, explaining that the videos the creator had posted on his channel violated the platform’s community guidelines.

Again, the warning strike you received was issued based on violation of Harmful or Dangerous Content which prohibits content that encourages or promotes dangerous behavior that encourages dangerous or illegal activities that risk serious physical harm or death.YouTube Support SpecialistAccording to Rich:"Ultimately, like I stated before, I understand that this is YouTube’s playground.

If they don’t want these types of videos on their platform, then we won’t make those types of videos on their platform. So, yes, I’m irritated that I have to self-censor myself on YouTube…But I’m going to swallow my pride, and I’m going to do what YouTube wants. It would just be nice to know if this is actually what YouTube wants, because again, they’re unwilling to tell me what I did wrong.

I have to make assumptions and guess.”Perhaps more interestingly, the YouTube tech enthusiast indicated that he believed Microsoft didn't have anything to do with the videos being taken down, even though he'd already premeditated that his audience would suggest as much. "YouTube must have made a deal with Microsoft," one ot the channel's followers indicated."

I don't think Microsoft had anything to do with it," added Rich. Instead, he shifted blame to Google and YouTube's over-reliance on AI, suggesting that his video was flagged by AI, and even when he made an appeal to have the video restored on a benign topic, the request was denied by AI. He further indicated that customer support was nothing but an AI chatbot made to make him feel like he was talking to a real person."

When computers hold the keys to the kingdom, there's simply no reasoning with a calculator," added Rich. "It's going to believe it's right no matter what you say because it's not programmed to reason."FAQCan you install Windows 11 without a Microsoft account?Until this month, it was possible to bypass Microsoft's requirement to set up Windows 11 without a Microsoft account.

However, Microsoft shipped a new update that blocks "known" loopholes, intending to make the requirement non-negotiable unless you use "Domain Account" setups on Windows 11 Pro.Why did YouTube flag a video demonstrating how to login into Windows 11 using only a local account?The YouTube creator says that he received communication from a support specialist (suspected to be AI) indicating that the video broke YouTube's community guidelines and policies, further indicating that it could lead to "serious physical harm or death."

Is Google and YouTube using AI to moderate content being uploaded online?According to CyberCPU's Rich, Google and YouTube's over-reliance on AI for content moderation and customer support is negatively impacting the platform's user experience, often leading to benign videos being misconstrued as harmful content, leading to a false positive.

Follow Windows Central on Google News to keep our latest news, insights, and features at the top of your feeds! Kevin Okemwa is a seasoned tech journalist based in Nairobi, Kenya with lots of experience covering the latest trends and developments in the industry at Windows Central. With a passion for innovation and a keen eye for detail, he has written for leading publications such as OnMSFT, MakeUseOf, and Windows Report, providing insightful analysis and breaking news on everything revolving around the Microsoft ecosystem.

While AFK and not busy following the ever-emerging trends in tech, you can find him exploring the world or listening to music.

Analysis

Conflict+
Related Info+
Core Event+
Background+
Impact+
Future+

Related Podcasts

YouTube 以“可能导致严重人身伤害或死亡”为由删除 Windows 11 本地账户绕过视频,创作者称“微软与此无关” | Goose Pod | Goose Pod