英国“增长危机”警报:就在Reeves关键预算发布前夕

英国“增长危机”警报:就在Reeves关键预算发布前夕

2025-12-07Business
--:--
--:--
雷总
哈喽 hanjf12,早上好!我是雷总。现在是12月8日星期一,晚上23点16分。欢迎来到 Goose Pod。今天我们要聊的话题有点沉重,但绝对硬核,关乎英国经济的“生死时速”。
董小姐
我是董小姐。hanjf12,别听雷总说得那么吓人,但事儿确实是个大事儿。英国现在的经济状况,用我的话说是“核心动力不足”。就在Reeves的关键预算发布前夕,警报拉响了。
雷总
没错,这次的警报简直就是一次严重的系统级 Bug。英国的一位内阁大臣彼得·凯尔亲口承认,英国正陷入一场“增长紧急状态”。这就好比我们发布了一款新手机,结果开机就蓝屏,主板都在发烫。更糟糕的是,距离财政大臣雷切尔·里夫斯发布那个决定她命运的预算案,只剩下不到两天时间了。这时候爆出这种消息,简直是公关灾难。
董小姐
这哪里是公关灾难,这是管理失职!我也看了报道,那个所谓的预算责任办公室,也就是OBR,准备下调英国未来几年的经济增长预期,一直下调到2029年。这意味着什么?意味着你这家“英国公司”未来五年的业绩报表全都要飘绿。作为管理者,这时候不想着怎么抓生产、提质量,反而在这儿喊救命,这要是我的员工,早被我骂醒了。
雷总
董小姐,您这脾气还是这么火爆。不过这OBR的预测确实是自成立15年来最悲观的一次。这就好比我们跑分软件显示,这台机器的性能不仅现在不行,未来五年还会持续降频。而且你知道吗,这让我想起了之前我们聊过的那个瑞银关于美国劳动力市场的报告。当时瑞银说美国那边是“浴缸出水口变大,进水口变小”,裁员创新高。现在看来,这不仅仅是美国的问题,英国这边的“操作系统”也卡顿得厉害,这是一种全球性的“算力衰退”。
董小姐
全球性也不是借口。企业要有企业的样子,国家要有国家的样子。里夫斯上任才18个月,当时的口号是“经济增长是第一任务”。现在呢?任务没完成,反而搞得人心惶惶。这就好比我承诺消费者要造出世界最好的空调,结果一年半过去,连风扇都转不起来。这不仅仅是数字问题,这是信心问题。那个彼得·凯尔虽然嘴上说有“乐观的理由”,但承认“紧急状态”本身就是一种认输。
雷总
确实,这种前后矛盾的表态,用户体验极差。一方面说处于“高税收、低增长”的死循环,另一方面又说能通过规划改革来解决。这种感觉就像是产品经理在发布会上说“我们硬件很烂,但我们软件优化会很好的”,这逻辑很难自洽啊。而且,这次预算案被称为“不成功便成仁”,里夫斯自己的职业生涯都悬于一线,压力比我们双十一冲销量还要大。
董小姐
双十一冲销量靠的是实打实的产品,他们现在靠什么?靠涨税?这就是典型的杀鸡取卵。如果核心科技掌握不了,如果生产力提不上去,光靠在账本上玩数字游戏,这家“公司”迟早要倒闭。英国现在的情况,就是典型的缺乏核心竞争力,还总想着通过涨价来维持利润,这在市场上是行不通的。
雷总
我们来给 hanjf12 详细拆解一下这个背景。这个OBR,全称是预算责任办公室,它其实就像是我们科技圈的第三方评测机构,比如DXOMARK,专门给政府的财政计划打分的。它是在2010年由前保守党财政大臣奥斯本设立的,目的就是为了防止政府在那儿“自吹自擂”,自己改PPT数据。这个机构每年两次发布五年预测,可以说是英国财政的“安兔兔跑分”。这次他们要下调预测,说明硬件底子确实不行了。
董小姐
哼,设立个监管机构是好事,但如果监管机构天天给你发整改通知书,那说明管理者有问题。彼得·凯尔在CBI,也就是英国工业联合会的会议上说,他们继承了一个烂摊子。这话我听着就耳熟,很多空降的高管最喜欢说“前任留下的坑”。他说英国被困在“高税收、低增长”的恶性循环里。这道理谁都懂,关键是你怎么破局?就像格力当年如果只抱怨市场环境不好,哪有今天的地位?你得去干,去解决问题,而不是在那儿开会找借口。
雷总
雷总我其实挺理解这种“接盘侠”的痛苦的。有时候代码写得像那啥山一样,重构起来确实难。凯尔虽然承认了紧急状态,但他后来对记者又强行挽尊,说有“很多乐观的理由”,比如希思罗机场的扩建支持,还有脱欧后的重置协议。这就像是我们虽然主板烧了,但我们换了个好看的手机壳,还贴了个高清膜。他试图用这些微小的利好来掩盖核心架构的崩塌。而且,里夫斯这次面临的压力特别大,因为她之前可是立了Flag的,要把经济增长搞上去。
董小姐
立Flag谁不会?关键是落地。CBI的总干事雷恩·牛顿-史密斯说得很直接:“如果你真的相信经济增长,那就证明给我们看。”这话说到我心坎里了。企业家看的是行动,不是你的PPT。现在的背景是,英国企业界已经因为各种不确定性被折腾得够呛了。预算案发布前的各种小道消息,什么要涨这个税、那个税,搞得大家人心惶惶。这就像我还没宣布新产品价格,外面就传言我们要涨价50%,经销商早就吓跑了。
雷总
对,这种“泄密营销”如果是故意的,那就太失败了;如果是无意的,说明管理混乱。凯尔还专门为此道了歉,说这些谣言让他也很沮丧。这不就是典型的“由于供应链原因,产品发货延迟”的官方话术吗?实际上,这背后反映的是英国财政的巨大黑洞。据报道,OBR之前就计划下调生产力预测,这就导致公共财政出现了大约200亿英镑的缺口。200亿啊,这得卖多少台手机才能赚回来?为了填这个坑,里夫斯现在是满世界找补丁打。
董小姐
填坑不能拿企业的命去填。背景里最讽刺的是,工党政府上台前承诺得好好的,现在却要拿私营部门开刀。他们所谓的“就业权利法案”,在企业看来就是增加用工成本。再加上可能的税收增加,这简直是在给正在爬坡的卡车轮胎上放气。海伦·米勒,财政研究所的主任,也警告说,如果搞出一堆乱七八糟的小税种,不仅收不到多少钱,还会把投资人都吓跑。这就像你为了省电,把工厂灯全关了,结果工人没法干活,最后亏得更多。
雷总
董小姐这个比喻太精准了。而且我们要注意到,保守党领袖凯米·巴德诺赫也在旁边“补刀”。她指责里夫斯把增税伪装成“必要之举”,实际上应该削减开支。这就像是两家竞争对手在打口水仗,一家说“你产品太贵”,另一家说“你成本控制不行”。但无论他们怎么吵,最终买单的用户——也就是英国的纳税人和企业,体验是实实在在的下降了。这个背景下的预算案,与其说是“增长计划”,不如说是一份“止损协议”。
董小姐
这就引出了最大的冲突点:政府想要钱,企业想要命。CBI那边警告说,企业正面临“千刀万剐式的税收死亡”。这词儿用得狠啊,但也真实。你想想,如果我也给我的供应商加一百个苛刻条款,他们早就不跟我玩了。现在的冲突在于,政府觉得企业是提款机,按一下就有钱出来;但企业觉得我是发动机,你把油断了,车就停了。这根本不是什么合作关系,这是博弈,是你死我活的博弈。
雷总
从程序员的角度看,这就是典型的资源争夺导致的死锁(Deadlock)。政府需要税收来修复由于生产力低下导致的财政Bug,但提高税收又反过来进一步降低了生产力,导致Bug更多。海伦·米勒提到的投资者神经紧张,这太真实了。资本是最聪明的,也是最胆小的。如果你这里的规则三天两头变,今天说要加这个税,明天说要改那个法,投资人肯定会Run。这就像安卓系统如果每个版本API都大改,开发者肯定都跑去写iOS了。稳定性是生态繁荣的前提啊。
董小姐
稳定?现在英国最缺的就是稳定。你看那个凯尔,一边道歉说谣言烦人,一边又在制造不确定性。冲突的另一个核心是关于“豪宅税”和“银行税”的争论。里夫斯想对200万英镑以上的房子下手,还想动银行。这听起来是劫富济贫,挺爽的,但实际上呢?这会打击高端人才和资本的积极性。你把有能力消费、有能力投资的人都赶走了,剩下的人喝西北风吗?做企业不能有仇富心理,要看谁能创造价值。你打击了创造价值的人,就是打击了整个经济的动力。
雷总
是的,这就是所谓的“流量反噬”。巴德诺赫建议废除“就业权利法案”,这其实是在试图降低系统的运行负载。但工党这边为了选票,为了所谓的“用户福利”,必须硬着头皮上。这就像是产品经理非要加一堆酷炫但耗电的功能,工程师说这会卡死,产品经理说“用户喜欢”。结果就是现在这种僵局。投资者在观望,企业在抱怨,政府在甩锅。这种冲突如果解决不好,英国经济别说增长了,能不崩盘就不错了。而且别忘了,还有那个“国民保险”的调整,这直接增加了企业的BOM(物料清单)成本,利润空间被进一步压缩。
董小姐
利润是企业的生命线!没有利润哪来的研发?哪来的创新?哪来的增长?政府现在是在杀鸡取卵,还嫌鸡下蛋太慢。这种冲突不仅仅是政策上的,更是观念上的。他们以为经济增长是可以通过行政命令“规划”出来的,简直是笑话。经济增长是企业一个螺丝钉一个螺丝钉拧出来的,是销售员一单甚至一单一单跑出来的。不尊重市场规律,不尊重企业主体,这种冲突迟早会爆发更大的危机。我看这个“增长紧急状态”不是天灾,是人祸。
雷总
要是真按这个剧本走,影响可就深远了。首先,那个传说中的“豪宅税”,针对10万套高价值房产,预计筹集4.5亿英镑。听起来不少,但对于200亿的缺口来说,这简直是杯水车薪,连个零头都不到。这更像是一个象征性的“皮肤”,为了安抚一部分用户情绪。但真正的杀招是雇主国民保险的增加,被称为“就业税”。这直接打击了企业的招聘意愿。就像我们刚才提到的瑞银报告里的美国情况,如果英国也把“进水口”堵死,失业率上来,消费降级,那整个生态链就断了。
董小姐
这就是典型的算小账算丢了大账。你为了那4个多亿,得罪了高端投资者;为了填补财政窟窿,加重了所有雇主的负担。结果是什么?企业不敢招人,甚至开始裁员。格力要是遇到这种税负环境,我也得考虑是不是要缩减规模或者搬迁产能了。这对英国本土的制造业、服务业打击是毁灭性的。而且,生产力预期被下调,意味着大家的工资涨幅会跑不赢通胀,老百姓手里的钱更不值钱,购买力下降,市场进一步萎缩。这就是一个完美的恶性循环闭环。
雷总
从数据的角度看,OBR的降级会直接影响英国的主权信用评级和借贷成本。这就好比一个人的芝麻信用分掉了,以后借钱利息更高。英国政府以后发债融资会更难,财政回旋余地更小。而且,这种悲观情绪是会传染的。一旦市场形成了“英国不行了”的共识,也就是所谓的“做空情绪”,那资本外流的速度会比我们想象的快得多。到时候,可能就不止是“增长危机”,而是“英镑危机”或者“债务危机”了。这对于全球投资者来说,也是一个巨大的风险信号。
董小姐
所以说,里夫斯这次不仅仅是在赌她自己的乌纱帽,是在拿英国的国运做赌注。如果这套组合拳打出去,不仅没把经济救活,反而把最后一口气打散了,那她就是历史的罪人。对于各方利益相关者来说,现在的策略只能是“现金为王”,收缩战线,准备过冬。不管是企业主还是普通打工人,都得勒紧裤腰带。这种影响,恐怕不是一两年能消除的,这是伤筋动骨的。
雷总
展望未来,周三就是那个“发布会”了。里夫斯到底会掏出什么“黑科技”还是“PPT造车”,马上揭晓。虽然现在各种传言满天飞,甚至还有所得税起征点冻结这种“隐形加税”的传闻,但不到最后一刻,谁也不知道最终参数。也许会有反转?也许会有更激进的措施?这就像等待一个不知道是惊喜还是惊吓的系统更新推送。但无论如何,数字化转型……哦不,经济转型的阵痛是免不了了。
董小姐
我从来不信什么惊喜,我只信实力。未来唯一的出路,就是老老实实搞实业,支持创新,把税负降下来,让企业敢干、愿干。如果周三的预算案还是玩虚的,还是搞平均主义那一套,那英国经济的冬天会很长。我们也得看看,这个所谓的“增长紧急状态”能不能真正打醒那些坐办公室的官僚。对于 hanjf12 来说,从这件事里能学到的就是:无论是管理公司还是管理个人财务,现金流和核心竞争力才是硬道理,别指望外部环境会突然变好。
雷总
总结一下,英国正面临严峻的“增长紧急状态”,OBR的预测降级和即将到来的增税预算案,让整个市场如履薄冰。这就是今天的 Goose Pod。感谢 hanjf12 的收听。
董小姐
只有潮水退去,才知道谁在裸泳。英国能不能挺过这一关,我们拭目以待。感谢收听 Goose Pod,我们明天见。

英国面临“增长紧急状态”,财政大臣Reeves的关键预算发布前夕,经济增长预期被大幅下调。内阁大臣承认危机,政府可能通过增税填补财政缺口,引发企业担忧,被指“杀鸡取卵”。此举或加剧“高税收、低增长”循环,影响国家信用和投资者信心。

Warning over UK ‘growth emergency’ just days before Reeves’ make-or-break Budget

Read original at The Independent

Britain is locked in a “growth emergency”, a senior cabinet minister has admitted, just hours after Rachel Reeves was dealt a fresh blow over the UK’s economic outlook. Two days before the chancellor stands up to deliver her second Budget, the government has been hit by revelations that the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the leading economic watchdog, will downgrade the country’s prospects and reduce its estimates for economic growth for every year until 2029.

The projections are expected to be the most pessimistic since the OBR was set up 15 years ago in the wake of the financial crisis.The news could not come at a worse time for the chancellor whose own job is believed to be on the line in a make or break Budget – just 18 months after she arrived in the Treasury with a “no 1 mission” of growing the economy.

Experts have also piled on the pressure, warning that measures expected in Ms Reeves’ Budget on Wednesday – including a form of mansion tax on high-value properties as well as a bank levy – will harm economic growth.Follow our live updates on the Budget hereOn Wednesday, the chancellor will reveal the government’s latest set of tax and spending policies (PA Wire)Speaking to business leaders at the CBI conference in Westminster, business secretary Peter Kyle admitted that the UK was in a “growth emergency”.

“We inherited a situation when we came into office where we [were] stuck in this buy-slight grip of high taxes and low growth, and we are not going to break out of this cycle unless we do some pretty profoundly different things”, he said in a bid to blame the Labour government’s inheritance. “I really think we have inherited [a] growth emergency, and we are still in it, and we will be in it for as long as we are unable to get our way out of this situation without increased economic productivity.

”But speaking to journalists at the conference after his speech, Mr Kyle claimed there was “a lot of reason for optimism” in the economy.He also cited changes to the planning system that would, for instance, support Heathrow expansion, as well as the UK’s post-Brexit reset deal with the EU and the expanded global talent visa.

However, his speech came amid warnings from businesses that instability and briefings in the run-up to the Budget - along with extra taxes on the private sector and a new wave of employment rights - had massively damaged growth in the UK.In her speech, CBI director general Rain Newton-Smith issued a challenge to the government: “If you really believe in economic growth, prove it.

”Peter Kyle addresses the CBI (Getty)She warned that instead of producing economic growth the businesses which were needed to deliver it were facing a “death by a thousands taxes.”Meanwhile, Helen Miller, director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, said Ms Reeves risks “increasing taxes that are bad for growth”, telling Times Radio that “investors will be nervous” if they see a list of tax increases.

“The danger is that if you do lots of small things, often our smaller taxes are particularly badly designed and therefore you can end up increasing taxes that are bad for growth.“Investors will be nervous if they see a list of tax increases, but don't quite trust how much revenue it will bring in”, she said.

Meanwhile, in her speech Tory leader Kemi Badenoch sought to capitalise on Labour’s economic woes.She accused Rachel Reeves of preparing to announce tax rises “dressed up as necessities. They are not. We need to cut spending”She also called on the chancellor to make “one easy cost free decision they can take - scrap the employment rights bill”.

Ms Reeves is reportedly set to impose a new mansion tax on more than 100,000 high-value properties as she seeks to raise money to fill the financial black hole, having reportedly scaled back plans for a property tax. She is expected to apply a tax to homes worth more than £2m in a move which could raise between £400m and £450m for the Treasury.

Prime minister Sir Keir Starmer and chancellor Rachel Reeves (Stefan Rousseau/PA) (PA Wire)Ms Reeves will deliver her Budget on Wednesday after a whirlwind of speculation about which taxes she will hike to help balance the books, including the expectation - and then apparent U-turn on - an increase to income tax.

The OBR will publish its latest forecasts following the chancellor’s Budget speech, with sources telling Sky News that it will downgrade its growth predictions for 2026 and for the remaining years of the current parliament. The downgrade is a result of a drop in expected productivity in the UK as part of a readjustment of previously incorrect estimates.

However, Ms Reeves’ own moves will also be blamed including imposing a hike in employer national insurance contributions in her first Budget in what has been dubbed “the jobs tax.”The OBR is an independent body which provides analysis of the nation's public finances and was set up in 2010 by former Tory chancellor George Osborne in the wake of the 2008 financial crash.

Twice a year, it publishes detailed five-year forecasts alongside the Budget and spring statement to assess the impact of any tax and spending measures and analyse whether the government is meeting its fiscal targets. Earlier this year it was reported that the OBR had planned to downgrade its official productivity forecasts, leaving a gap in the public finances of around £20bn and prompting fears of widespread tax rises to fill the gap and rescue Britain’s ailing public finances.

An extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds is among rumoured measures and would see more people dragged into paying tax for the first time or shifted into a higher rate as their wages go up.Among the “smorgasbord” of tax rises which are expected, Ms Reeves is also set to scrap the two-child benefit cap and expected to introduce a gambling tax.

The latest reports about the OBR’s growth downgrade came just hours after Mr Kyle apologised for the speculation around the Budget and said that rumours have been “as frustrating for me and the chancellor as it has for everyone else”.He told BBC Breakfast there is “intense pressure” on ministers to be “open about the direction of travel...

while staying within the confines of what’s acceptable for a Budget”.“I’m sorry that people have been anxious about all the speculation, it’s been as frustrating for me and the chancellor as it has for everyone else”, he said. The Treasury has been contacted for comment.

Related Podcasts